Quotulatiousness

November 22, 2026

Resolved: “That this House will under no circumstances fight for its King and country”

Filed under: Britain, History, Politics — Tags: , — Nicholas @ 04:00

The Oxford Union’s February 1933 debate is perhaps one of the best-known controversies in 20th century British history … yet if the same issue were debated today, would anyone be surprised if the result wasn’t the same?

Debate Chamber of the Oxford Union Society
Photo by Barker Evans via Wikimedia Commons.

For an event that is usually dismissed as little more than a footnote of history, it is remarkable just how often the 1933 Oxford Union King and Country debate has been invoked by historians and commentators over the years. But before examining the debate’s ongoing relevance, it is important to understand the historical context around that infamous night in February 1933.

Given the state of the world at the time, few could have failed to notice that the years surrounding the debate were punctuated by one crisis after another. Indeed, following the Wall Street Crash, the Manchurian Crisis, the stalled efforts at Geneva to reduce international armaments and — barely ten days before the debate — Adolf Hitler’s appointment as Chancellor of Germany, it appeared to many that the world was determined to sow the seeds of its own destruction.

Perhaps not surprisingly, young people in particular had their illusions shattered by these seismic events. But unlike their French counterparts of today, Oxford students in 1933 did not express their frustration and anger by assaulting the police and torching national monuments. Instead, they donned formal evening wear, had dinner, and then walked into the Union’s august chamber to take part in a debate.

Although not quite as devastating as the scenes of wanton destruction we have witnessed across France in recent weeks, the outcome of that notorious debate at the Oxford Union on 9 February 1933 nevertheless sent shockwaves around the world. Despite the best efforts of Quintin Hogg, who opposed the motion and would go on to serve in Margaret Thatcher’s government, a clear majority of members voted that they would under no circumstances fight for their King and Country. In a Britain that was still in many ways consciously patriotic, but also anxious about the immediate future, the vote touched a nerve.

For months after the debate, letters expressing outrage and condemnation flooded the newspapers. The students were vilified — mostly by an older generation shaped by the values of martial valour — as cowards, pacifists and “woozy-minded communists”. They were attacked as “effete, effeminate, side-whispered”, and dismissed as “no good to God or man”.

When news of the debate spread beyond Britain’s shores, the “Oxford Oath”, as it became known, caused alarm in a host of British embassies, ranging from Madrid to Santiago. Not only was the vote reported by press agencies around the world, but university students from all over the English-speaking world staged copycat debates, with many producing a similar outcome.

Back at home, as the media backlash showed no sign of abating, the formidable Lady Houston, who never bothered to conceal her hatred for anything that even smelt of pacifism, saw the vote as symbolic of the younger generation’s degeneracy. Her response was to send a box containing 275 white feathers to the Union President, one for each “coward” who had dared to vote for the motion.

Actually, given the demographic and cultural changes at Oxford over the years, one suspects that the vote might favour fighting against King and country these days …

QotD: Working in a bookshop

Filed under: Books, Britain, Business, Quotations — Tags: , — Nicholas @ 01:00

If you were working on the ground floor, you could play a game with yourself or a like-minded colleague (not a given) where you guessed the type of customer from the moment that they entered the front door. If they were heading to the sci-fi/fantasy section (yes, yes, they’re different) this was not too difficult. Likewise, the true crime corner – the shop being quite close to HMP *REDACTED* – though one was less likely to snigger openly at those people. Within the overwhelmingly dominant fiction floorspace, one would have to make more-particular assessments: colour of jacket (the book, but maybe also the customer), quantity of gold lettering (ditto), ratio of author’s name to title, that sort of thing.

Alas (not really, though), I was generally stationed on the first floor – History, Politics, Philosophy, Music, Poetry – with which my interests were more naturally aligned. This was the haunt of middle-aged men, or wives shopping on middle-aged-men’s behalves. A person sporting cords and flat brown shoes (gender irrelevant) could easily be headed anywhere within the first floor’s offerings.

The one place I would practically beg not to be sent was to the top floor, where there had once been a decent cafe that my mother would take me too, en route to choir or a violin lesson, but where now they kept the children’s books – especially, the ones that, when a small kid touches them, emit a basic, synthesised tune that cannot be silenced or changed, even with heavy objects. Just covering this section for someone’s lunch hour could induce a nasty case of PTSD.

A.S.H. Smyth, “Seven kinds of people you find in bookshops”, The Critic, 2020-11-14.

November 21, 2026

Brits “hold the political class in almost universal contempt”

Filed under: Britain, Government, Media, Politics — Tags: , , , , , — Nicholas @ 03:00

In The New English Review, Theodore Dalrymple discusses the crisis of government in the UK, as no party seems to be able to get out of their own way on multiple issues:

Then-Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer visiting Holy Trinity Church of England Primary School in Manchester on 13 April 2026 with Andy Burnham, Mayor of Greater Manchester.
Picture by Lauren Hurley / No 10 Downing Street via Wikimedia Commons.

Every nation has the government it deserves, wrote Joseph de Maistre in 1811 — a deceptively simple statement containing both truth and falsehood. What, after all, did I do, and millions like me, to deserve the government of former Prime Minister Keir Starmer (or, for that matter, any of Britain’s recent governments)? After all, 80 percent of the population did not vote for him.

On the other hand, no government emerges fully formed, like Venus from the sea, without cultural, political, economic, psychological, and social antecedents. In a representative democracy, our rulers represent us in more than one sense. A country’s political class mirrors its population; what we see in that mirror in Britain is far from reassuring.

The population holds the political class in almost universal contempt. It has been a long time since I have heard anything neutral, let alone complimentary, said about it — anything other than, “They are all the same”, or “They are all in it for themselves”. I often join that chorus myself. But when someone concludes that voting is therefore pointless, I part company. There is always a better and a worse. One votes not so much for a politician as against the alternatives.

Careerism, opportunism, and narcissism are the faith, hope, and charity of today’s political class, sometimes combined with bad ideas. An absence of character seems almost a requirement for our leaders, sometimes seemingly inscribed on their faces. Looking at the blankness of David Cameron, say, or of Starmer, what character, other than an absence of character, appears there? Unfortunately, an absence of character, unmarked by either life or experience, is not incompatible with great ambition. Indeed, ambition becomes the substitute for character.

The one recent exception, perhaps, was Boris Johnson, but he had personality rather than character: moreover, a personality that he invented for himself and carefully curated. In one devastating anecdote, which I have noted before, he emerges from an elevator and, thinking himself unobserved, looks into the mirror opposite and musses up his hair to make it look as though he had just got out of bed. Dishevelment, be thou my elegance, for the sake of the public image I am creating.

Unlike other recent leaders, Johnson was unafraid to make a joke for fear of offending a voter, a fear that leads inexorably to the grimmest of combinations: earnestness without seriousness. But a man playing a part long enough, even that of a buffoon, eventually becomes what he pretends to be. He ends as a character actor, not a man of character.

The political class is responsible for decisions with profound consequences, and incompetence and stupidity at the top are bound not so much to trickle as to pour torrentially over the rest of society.

Gordon Brown, when finance minister, sold more than half of Britain’s gold reserves — already less than a third of what they had been in 1950 — between 1999 and 2002, at a profound low in the price of gold. He overruled advice not to do so and, by the method of sale he chose, depressed the price still further, securing the worst possible deal for the country just before gold began its dizzying ascent. This astonishing act of intellectual hubris, as though Brown had glimpsed the final demise of gold as a store of value after three or four millennia, has cost the country tens of billions in reserves. Yet it carried no political cost: he became prime minister in 2007. Though by no means as avid for adulation as his erstwhile master, Anthony (“Call me Tony”, now Sir Tony) Blair, he is still sometimes presented, or wheeled out, as a wise elder statesman of public policy. Perhaps his lack of common sense, fortified by a dash of ideology, was only what one might have expected of a Ph.D. in history and a former lecturer in politics at Edinburgh University and the Glasgow College of Technology.

Our senior politicians appear to live in a looking-glass world. They have only to be confronted with a choice to make the wrong one. I am reminded of a student in my long-distant past who consistently scored lower on multiple-choice examinations than chance would have predicted. It was as though he possessed a kind of knowledge, but the mirror image of the true variety.

November 20, 2026

Protecting vulnerable women from predatory men

Filed under: Britain, Health, Law, Media, Politics — Tags: , , , — Nicholas @ 05:00

First, we must agree that adult women are competent, responsible individuals with their own agency, right? No debate about it. Except … we’re not always supposed to hold women responsible when it comes to their personal relationships, for reasons:

Russell Brand and friends (Brand is the one with the heaviest eye make-up).

Following the conviction of Russell Brand, Joanna Gray has asked why some women are drawn to “promiscous and predatory men”.

Her answer is that some women suffer the aftershocks of a childhood lacking in proper fatherly love. Such women seek to satisfy their “deep biological imperative to mate”, only they may do so with the wrong kind of men.

How might these women be protected, asks the lead to Gray’s article.

On Gray’s account, 3.1 million girls in England and Wales experience living apart from one of their biological parents – mostly their father.

This means that the number of women who are vulnerable in the way that Gray describes – women whose emotional development was seriously adversely affected by lack of a loving father in a manner to be taken into account and protected – is potentially enormous.

And that number does not even include those women who grew up in outwardly stable family homes where the father was nonetheless often or mostly absent or inattentive.

The question that follows from Gray’s argument, therefore, is whether it is possible to reliably take any woman as a consenting adult, or whether so many women may have been so emotionally starved as girls that even their explicit consent must be understood and protected as the unconscious expression of an elongated pattern of compulsion.

Gray writes that “it is encouraging that the law is finally catching up with some of the rape gang perpetrators, Brand and others”.

In listing Brand alongside the rape gang perpetrators, Gray surreptitiously diminishes a categorical difference between them: victims of the rape gangs are typically underage girls; Brand’s accusers are almost all adult women.

Gray thereby exposes her basic position, which is that adult women who engage with promiscuous men are effectively underage to the extent that they are playing out the emotional conditions of their girlhood.

On this account, there is little or no difference between the moral, perhaps also the legal, status of underage girls and some (3.1 million or more?) seeming-women. The first are not consenting adults because they are not adults. The second are not consenting adults: either because they only seem to be consenting, or because it is impossible to tell if they only seem to be consenting or are really consenting.

There is a trend for reframing adult people as so subject to systems, structures, inputs of all kinds, that they are not truly autonomous.

Adult people are everywhere described as pawns of a force beyond their ken or control, be it white privilege, patriarchal entitlement, the post-colonial condition or childhood trauma.

This justifies the administration of adult people, not as free agents but en masse: by edicts from national and supra-national governments or by health, education and other programmes aimed at demographics or even entire populations.

The view of millions of adult women as mired in their girlhood, living out the effects of neglect by fathers and therefore in need of protection (what kind of protection? protection by whom?) participates in this trend, which denigrates the rational autonomy of adult people by the emphasis on large-scale forces that operate upon them.

November 19, 2026

What Medieval People Ate When Traveling

Filed under: Britain, Food, History — Tags: , , , , , — Nicholas @ 02:00

Tasting History with Max Miller
Published 19 May 2026

Bars of pine nut, ginger, and honey candy

City/Region: England
Time Period: c. 1390

Travelers have always loved snacks. For me, it’s peanut M&Ms. For the medieval European, it might’ve been something like this candy. Bringing your own food was recommended by medieval travel guides, and it needed to be things that would keep and travel well. The classic go-to was hardtack (clack clack), but something much tastier is this pine nut candy. While not everyone could afford it as sugar was quite expensive, it would be a welcome treat on the road for those who could.

This candy can either be chewy, hard like a brittle, or somewhere in between based on how hot you cook the sugar. Mine was in between, and it was absolutely delicious. The pine nuts are the dominant flavor, and you get the hint of ginger at the very end. Feel free to customize this candy even further by adding different spices or nuts. Cinnamon, galangal, black pepper, almonds, and hazelnuts would all be delicious and period appropriate.

    Payn ragoun
    Take honey and sugar of cyprus and clarify them together, and boil it with easy fire, and keep it well from burning and when it hath boiled a while, take up a drop thereof with the finger and do it in a little water, and look if it hangs together; and take it from the fire and do thereto pinenuts the thriddendele & powdered ginger, and stir it together till it begin to thicken, and cast it on a wet table; cut it in strips and serve forth with fried meat, on flesh days or on fish days.
    — The Forme of Cury, c. 1390

(more…)

November 16, 2026

Caning British children: where did they get the canes?

Filed under: Britain, Education, History — Tags: , , — Nicholas @ 05:00

I have to admit that even though I was aware that the use of the cane for disciplining schoolboys was an accepted part of the British public school system (that is, the exclusive private schools, not the later state-run institutions), I’d never given a thought to where they obtained their implements of juvenile correction … but Suzanne Zeedyk has:

Image from Suzanne Zeedyk on Substack

I wrote recently about the history of the belt in Scottish schools, focusing on the ways in which commercial interests helped to sustain this brutal practice. I enjoyed hearing from readers who found my observations discomforting. One primary teacher commented that he “actually had to sit down” upon reading that a miniature strap had been available to order, “intended for use on very small children or as a toy, at a cost of only 33p”.

My research for that piece left me wondering about the history of the cane in English and Welsh schools. Who manufactured those devices? How much did they cost? How were they marketed to schools? And what was the impact on that income stream once corporal punishment was banned in schools? These are fascinating questions because they have been largely overlooked. The passage of time seems to have robbed us of an awareness that canes were commercial products, purchased by schools as a form of equipment, in much the same spirit as sporting or music equipment. The purpose of that “punishment equipment” was dark, of course, in that its intention was to cause children pain. This purpose was one that manufacturers endorsed. Indeed, they were making money from it.

This history deserves to be better understood, not just for its own sake, but because it illuminates the way in which denial operates. That is the central aim of this series – to explore the role that denial plays in obstructing change that improves children’s lives. When we look back to practices that have now been discarded, we increase the possibility of seeing where we might be living in denial today. Those discoveries are always uncomfortable. They reveal things about ourselves and our culture that we might prefer to ignore. That’s why I call this stance “Fierce Curiosity”. When you have to look at things that are uncomfortable, when ordinary levels of curiosity won’t do, when it takes courage to look – that’s when you need Fierce Curiosity.

Debate continues today about how to manage the behaviour of children and young people in schools. Should isolation booths and silent corridors be adopted? Or should nurture practices and trauma-informed policies be put in place? Tension rises sharply between advocates of these two camps. Perhaps examining previous debates can yield insights that will help in making sense of these modern ones?

Tracing commercial aspects of school corporal punishment in the 1970s and 1980s turns out to be useful in this regard.1

The design and use of canes

Before we turn our attention to suppliers, let me describe the design and use of canes. This ensures that everyone is aware of the ways in which this “equipment” was applied to the bodies of children and young people.

Canes came in two basic styles. The first was the “swishy cane”, like the ones that feature in the schoolboy stories of Billy Bunter. This style was thin and bendy, intended to leave a burning sting. It was typically a straight stick with a wrapped handle added to one end, making it easier for the teacher to hang on to. The second style was stiffer and thicker, usually fashioned into the shepherd’s crook handle that has come to be thought of as a “Headmaster’s cane”. This style had a wider diameter, about the width of a thumb, which landed on a child’s lower body with a kind of thud. It left a deeper reverberating pain, rather than the burning sensation of the swishy cane.

[…]

Coopers of England

Coopers of England was a stalwart supplier of punishment canes, even though that wasn’t their primary activity. Fundamentally, they were a gentleman’s accessories outfitter, with a reputation for tradition and prestige. First established in 1850, on a country estate in Surrey emblematic of the Victorian age, Coopers came, over time, to be regarded as Britain’s oldest and biggest walking stick maker. An article published in 1994 in The Observer describes their beautiful, high-quality products, fashioned from any type of wood (or other sturdy plant, like rattan) into any style of cane one wished. A single sentence in the article captures the unexpected intersection of privilege and punishment, when it describes Coopers in this way:

    Purveyor of walking sticks and umbrellas to the gentry, and of canes to schools all over Britain, for the last 150 years.

That unsettling sentence deserves to be read slowly: “Purveyor of … canes to schools all over Britain”. And then there’s the even more startling sentence at the beginning of the piece: “The shop is a sadistic headmaster’s dream”.


  1. My sincere thanks go to Colin Farrell, who oversees the World Corporal Punishment Research initiative. This article would have been impossible to write without access to the extensive archive of materials he has compiled, which he makes available to the public at no cost. https://www.corpun.com

As I commented to James Ross, who restacked the original article:

Coopers of England was a stalwart supplier of punishment canes, even though that wasn’t their primary activity. Fundamentally, they were a gentleman’s accessories outfitter, with a reputation for tradition and prestige.

That tracks. The old public schools would have preferred a more refined source of their torture implements than just a shop on the high street … when caning blue-blooded bottoms, only the finest quality tools should be used …

Or am I overthinking this?

QotD: Scottish recruits

Filed under: Britain, History, Humour, Law, Military, Quotations, WW1 — Tags: , , — Nicholas @ 01:00

If you answer a sergeant as you would a foreman, you are impertinent; if you argue with him, as all good Scotsmen must, you are insubordinate; if you endeavour to drive a collective bargain with him, you are mutinous; and you are reminded that upon active service mutiny is punishable by death. It is all very unusual and upsetting.

Ian Hay (Major John Hay Beith), The First Hundred Thousand: Being the Unofficial Chronicle of a Unit of “K(1)”, 1916.

November 14, 2026

The Harry Potter books to Millenials are like Lord of the Rings to boomers

Filed under: Books, Britain, Media — Tags: , , , , , — Nicholas @ 03:00

On the social media site formerly known as Twitter, Devon Eriksen considers the relevance of J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter books to the Millennials:

After some recent trends, I finally decide to read the Harry Potter books.

And I came away with something I didn’t expect.

I came away with an understanding of what makes a generationally beloved classic.

It isn’t authorial skill. Rowling is certainly talented, but, at least at the time, she was also relatively unpolished, and the series has plenty of rough patches. Uneven pacing, awkward plots, exposition dumps, two-dimensional secondary characters. I could write quite a few lines about what might be fixed. And I probably will at some point.

But none of that matters.

Because a generationally beloved classic is almost never the best book of a generation. A generationally beloved classic is the book that most perfectly captures what that generation yearns for.

Hogwart’s School of Wizardry did that for millennials, just as the quest to destroy the One Ring did so for the boomers.

Boomers grew up hearing tales of recent history, and the heroism of previous generations, who got us through the great depression, and the great war. Their father, or grandfathers, or both, were heroes. But they were left growing up in the 1950s, a near-ideal time of growth, happiness, and prosperity.

Near-ideal isn’t ideal. Humans need goals. The boomers were left with no great struggles to fight, no great tasks to do, nothing that could make them feel like they measured up.

So they invented something. A new struggle. A moral struggle. They decided that, because the great depression, and the great war, had happened when the institutions of Western Civilization existed, therefore those institutions were responsible. That those institutions needed to be torn down, gutted, and rebuilt in the new Boomer Morality.

This was their great quest, what allowed them to imagine themselves heroes. As an added bonus, it allowed them to imagine that the men who fought WW2 were not. They were, after all, adherents of the old creed.

When the hippies took to the streets, chanting “fascist scum, your time has come”, they meant the very same people who had fought the Nazis.

Lord of the Rings dovetailed perfectly into this narrative. Its central struggle, its great quest, is not a martial struggle or a political struggle, but a moral struggle … the quest not to seize an object of power, but to destroy one.

Frodo was not some great warrior, or wise wizard. He was an innnocent, whose virtue was moral worth. The young, unaccomplished, and very small man had to resist the temptations of power, and to destroy it, because it was wicked.

Is it any wonder that the boomers decided to tear down and hollow out the institutions of society, rather than inherit and incrementally improve them?

Even to this day, any younger person who seeks power, wanting to improve the world, is subjected to any number of brain-dead aphorisms about Boromir and the Ring.

Never mind that Tolkien never intended any of this. Never mind that the Ring wasn’t a symbol of anything. It was a ring. It was evil not because it represented power … it was simply evil because it was made by evil for evil purposes, and possessed a malign will of its own.

LOTR, the way the boomers read it, fit perfectly into their worldview, and they imagine themselves perpetual revolutionaries, always fighting the evils of power, even now when they are 70 years old and own everything.

Which brings us to millennials. They grew up in the world that the gutting of Western institutions left us. They went to government schools run by characters straight out of a Franz Kafka novel, sent there by parents who inexplicably hated them from the time they were old enough to talk.

When they yearned, they didn’t yearn for a great moral struggle, or to tear anything down, or to be revolutionaries.

They yearned for a society that cared about them, for parents who loved them, for a civilization that saw them as the future, and invested in them accordingly.

They wanted to go to Hogwart’s. They wanted get a letter by owl, telling them that the reason they didn’t quite fit wasn’t because they were inadequate, but because they were special.

They wanted to be the special ones, the chosen ones, the boys and girls who lived. And that last sentence may sound a bit conceited … until you realized that when they wanted to be special, they wanted to be special in precisely the way that Harry Potter was special, the way that every child in a healthy family is naturally special … not because he is talented or great, but because his mother loved him.

This is what saved Harry Potter in the inciting incident of his young life. This is what millennials wanted for themselves. Not to be astronauts and war heroes and rock stars, but to fit into a place like Hogwarts. To be mentored by wise and caring elders like Dumbledore. To be part of a community. To have mothers who loved them.

To write a story like this isn’t necessarily to understand a generation, because it never seems to happen except by accident.

It is, rather, to help a generation understand itself.

That’s why fan fiction, with visions like this picture, matters. Not because it has so large a footprint as to change the world, perhaps, but because it represents the spirit of an age.

It tells us what people want. And if we look carefully, it tells us why.

Why Challenger 3 Changes Everything

Filed under: Britain, History, Middle East, Military, Technology, Weapons — Tags: , , , , , , , , — Nicholas @ 02:00

The Tank Museum
Published 24 Jul 2026

Born with the best armour, forged in the desert, and now one of the most advanced designs in the world the Challenger line is the pinnacle of heavy armoured warfare. And for the very first time, all three came together here at TANKFEST 2026. To mark this occasion, we’re going to unpack what makes the Challenger one of the most formidable Main Battle Tanks in the world.

00:00 | Introduction
00:57 | Goodbye Cold War. Goodbye Chieftain
09:24 | Two is Better Than One
17:42 | Three’s a Charm
19:55 | Time for a Change

This video features archive footage courtesy of British Pathé.

In this video, join Chris Copson for a deep dive into the family history of Britain’s main battle tank – the Challenger. From the unrivalled firepower of Challenger 1, to the incredible armour of Challenger 2, and now to the digital upgrades of Challenger 3, this family’s evolution has gone from strength to strength. Both Challengers 1 and 2 have done sterling service with the British Army, but is Challenger 3 the tank of the future?

November 12, 2026

The corporate bailout that caused the Boston Tea Party

Filed under: Britain, Food, History, USA — Tags: , , , , , , — Nicholas @ 02:00

Tasting History with Max Miller
Published 15 May 2026

Slightly thickened warm drink made of green tea, white wine, and nutmeg

City/Region: England | United States of America
Time Period: 1742

Caudles are one of those old-fashioned drinks that you don’t hear about anymore, but they should really make a comeback, or at least this green tea caudle should. Originally, the term caudle referred to any hot drink, but over time, caudle came to mean a drink made with wine or ale that was thickened, sweetened, and spiced.

This caudle, from an English cookbook that was the first cookbook printed in the American colonies, has a base of green tea and wine that is sweetened with sugar, spiced with nutmeg, and thickened with egg yolks. The green tea and nutmeg really come through, and there’s an interesting citrusy flavor that I think comes from the sauvignon blanc that I used. The egg yolks gently thicken the mixture so it has the consistency of egg nog, and overall it is a unique, delicious drink that is well worth a try.

    To make Tea Caudle.
    Make a quart of strong green Tea, and pour it out into a Skillet, and set it over the fire; then beat the yolks of four Eggs, and mix with them a pint of White-wine, a grated Nutmeg, Sugar to your Taste, and put all together; and stir it over the fire till ‘tis very hot, then drink it in China Dishes as Caudle.
    — The Compleat Housewife: or, Accomplish’d Gentlewoman’s Companion by Eliza Smith, 1734

(more…)

November 11, 2026

In memoriam

Filed under: Britain, History, Military, WW1, WW2 — Tags: , , — Nicholas @ 03:00

A simple recognition of some of our family members who served in the First and Second World Wars:

The Great War

  • A Poppy is to RememberPrivate William Penman, Scots Guards, died 16 May, 1915 at Le Touret, age 25
    (Elizabeth’s great uncle)
  • Private Archibald Turner Mulholland, Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders, mortally wounded 25 September, 1915 at Loos, age 27
    (Elizabeth’s great uncle)
  • Private David Buller, Highland Light Infantry, died 21 October, 1915 at Loos, age 35
    (Elizabeth’s great grandfather)
  • Private Harold Edgar Brand, East Yorkshire Regiment. died 4 June, 1917 at Tournai.
    (My first cousin, three times removed)
  • Private Walter Porteous, Durham Light Infantry, died 4 October, 1917 at Passchendaele, age 18
    (my great uncle, who had married the day before he left for the front and never returned)
  • Corporal John Mulholland, Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders, wounded 2 September, 1914 (shortly before the First Battle of the Aisne), wounded again 29 June, 1918, lived through the war.
    (Elizabeth’s great uncle)
  • John Eleazar (“Ellar”) Thornton, (rank and dates of service unknown, served in the Royal Garrison Artillery, the East Surrey Regiment, and the Essex Regiment (he likely joined the RGA in 1899). Put on the “Z” list after the war — recall list. He died in an asylum in 1943.
    (my grandfather’s eldest brother)
  • Henry (Harry) Thornton, (uncertain) Lancashire Fusiliers. (We are not sure it is him as there were no identifying family or birth date listed. Rejected for further service.)
    (my grandfather’s second older brother)
  • Rifleman James Albert Conn, Royal Irish Rifles. He was discharged 23 Jan 1915 with a gunshot wound to the left elbow and granted a disability pension. A sad irony: he was shot dead in the streets of Belfast during the 1920 Irish Uprising. He ran out onto the road to help a man who had been shot and was killed by British troops (age 32).
    (Elizabeth’s great granduncle.)

The Second World War

  • Flying Officer Richard Porteous, Royal Air Force, survived the defeat in Malaya and the surrender of Singapore, was evacuated to India and lived through the war.
    (my great uncle)
  • Able Seaman John Penman, Royal Navy, served in the Defensively Equipped Merchant fleet on the Atlantic convoys, the Murmansk Run (we know he spent a winter in Russia at some point during the war) and other convoy routes, was involved in firefighting and rescue efforts during the Bombay Docks explosion in 1944, lived through the war.
    (Elizabeth’s father. We received his Arctic Star medal in July, 2024.)
  • Private Archie Black (commissioned after the war and retired as a Major), Gordon Highlanders, captured during the fall of Singapore (aged 15) and survived a Japanese POW camp (he had begun to write an autobiography shortly before he died)
    (Elizabeth’s uncle)
  • Elizabeth Buller, “Lumberjill” in the Women’s Timber Corps, an offshoot of the Women’s Land Army in Scotland through the war.
    (Elizabeth’s mother)
  • Trooper Leslie Taplan Russon, 3rd Royal Tank Regiment, died at Tobruk, 19 December, 1942 (aged 23).
    (My father’s first cousin, once removed and therefore my first cousin, twice removed).
  • Flight Sergeant Kenneth Alexander Porteous, Royal Air Force, air gunner in a Lancaster bomber of 15 Squadron, Bomber Command. Died when his plane was shot down at Wormlitz 10 miles northeast of the target during a raid on Magdeburg, 21 January 1944 (aged 28).
    (My first cousin, twice removed.)
  • Reginald Thornton, rank and branch of service unknown, hospitalized during the war with shellshock and was never discharged back into civilian life. He died in York in 1986.
    (My grandfather’s youngest brother)

My maternal grandfather, Matthew Kendrew Thornton, was in a reserved occupation during the war as a plater working at Smith’s Docks in Middlesbrough. The original design for the famous Flower-class corvettes came from Smith’s Docks which also launched 16 of the 196 built in the UK during the war (more were built in Canada). My great-grandmother was an enthusiastic ARP warden through the war (she reportedly enjoyed enforcing blackout compliance in the neighbourhood using the rattle and whistle that came with the job). My father was just a bit too young to serve, and discovered when he tried to join the army in late 1945 that the very last thing the British army wanted at that time was yet another officer cadet. By a weird timing issue, he then was too old for National Service when it was introduced a few years later. My father never did forgive the army …

For the curious, the Commonwealth War Graves Commission the Royal British Legion, and the Library and Archives Canada WW1 and WW2 records site provide search engines you can use to look up your family name. The RBL’s Every One Remembered site shows you everyone who died in the Great War in British or Empire service (Canadians, Australians, New Zealanders, South Africans and other British colonies). The CWGC site also includes those who died in the Second World War. Library and Archives Canada allows searches of the Canadian Expeditionary Force and the Royal Newfoundland Regiment for all who served during WW1, and including those who volunteered for the CEF but were not accepted.

In Flanders fields the poppies blow
Between the crosses row on row,
That mark our place; and in the sky
The larks, still bravely singing, fly
Scarce heard amid the guns below.

We are the Dead. Short days ago
We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow,
Loved and were loved, and now we lie
In Flanders fields.

Take up our quarrel with the foe:
To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high.
If ye break faith with us who die
We shall not sleep, though poppies grow
In Flanders fields.

Lieutenant Colonel John McCrae, MD, Canadian Army Medical Corps (1872-1918)

Here is Mark Knopfler’s wonderful song “Remembrance Day” from his Get Lucky album, set to a slideshow of British and Canadian images from World War I through to more recent conflicts put together by Bob Oldfield:

What Life in the WW1 Trenches Was Really Like

The Rest Is History
Published 18 May 2026

During the First World War, what was it like to live in the trenches on the Western Front in 1915? How did the Germans attempt to knock the Allies out of the war right from the outset? And, what secret weapon did the Germans unleash?

Join Dominic and Tom as they plunge back into the First World War, and carry us through life in the trenches, the horrors of shelling, and the escalation of this totemic conflict.

00:00 The Western Front
02:34 Robert Graves goes to war
06:27 Marching towards the trenches
10:06 Bullets, dugouts and the first casualty
13:24 Daily life in the trenches
16:19 How the trenches were built
18:51 Mud, slime and being trapped
20:01 Lice, fleas and trench fever
22:08 Rats in the trenches
23:49 Boredom, routine and why some soldiers enjoyed it
26:31 Life behind the front line
28:52 The Times
30:05 Ernst Jünger and the horror of battle
33:23 Storm of Steel
36:20 The “great god Pain”
40:25 Face-to-face killing
43:49 The odds of death on the Western Front
45:41 Shell shock
49:26 How the army understood trauma
51:19 Every soldier’s breaking point
54:21 Gas: Germany’s secret weapon
57:14 The first gas attacks
59:03 Wilfred Owen and the horror of gas
1:02:03 Britain’s disastrous gas attack at Loos
1:04:40 John Kipling and the tragedy of Loos

November 10, 2026

“I felt like Howard Carter entering Tutankhamun’s tomb and waving a torch at the walls of hieroglyphics”

Filed under: Britain, Media, Technology — Tags: , , , , , , — Nicholas @ 05:00

Have you noticed that the widespread availability of emojis/emoticons/electroheiroglyphics has particularly influenced how younger folks communicate? Joanna Gray has, and has her concerns about the whole thing:

One of the markers future historians will use when describing the New Dark Ages will be the collapse in the use of the alphabet in favour of “Yookay Hieroglyphics”. A demoralising development has emerged: a whole new form of pictographic language whereby children and young adults engage in hours-long online conversations with each other without the need for any letters, texts or words. Such conversations largely occur on gaming platforms, Snapchat and WhatsApp, and mark a classic regressive step in civilisational decline.

Like the medieval laity who relied on church wall paintings and stained glass to learn stories, a growing proportion of our current population is now using only pictographic communication. This time, there is no divine knowledge behind the imagery – just inane slop. I shall try to use words to describe this new pictographic language that groups of teenagers I work with have shared with me. When first shown, I felt like Howard Carter entering Tutankhamun’s tomb and waving a torch at the walls of hieroglyphics in wonderment. Yookay Hieroglyphics are read vertically from top to bottom. If drawn on Snapchat, they often instantly disappear on reading or after 31 days, making linguistic analysis particularly fraught.

A useful starting point when attempting to read Yookay Hieroglyphics is to think of the wonderfully coloured whizzy strip of cherries, bananas, apples, horseshoes, numbers, etc. on a slot machine. Reams and reams of such images are being sent from one person to another within microseconds. It often begins with one pictographic innovator (teenager) photographing their face and sending their image; their friend replies with their face; what then follows is a rapid exchange of images from one to another, creating a roll of vertically read hieroglyphics: distorted face, laughing emoji, pic of pet, pet pic distorted, laughing face, feeling sick emoji, question mark, toilet gif, sick emoji, prayer emoji, pic of dragon, happy face, pic of person smiling, distorted pic, AI-ed moving image of that pic, cat video, pic of nails, nail art inspo, gif witch nails, cross face, face with witch filter on, lol emoji, pic of face with wizard filter, pic of wizard distorted, instantly made sticker of that image, lol emoji, red laser coming out of wizard eyes filter, OMG emoji … and on and on and on and on and on.

Because I am not of the emerging linguist tribe, I will be unable to fully convey the nuances and depth of the meaning in this sample conversation – indeed a paper has concluded that emoji-based language is more layered in adolescents than in adults.

November 9, 2026

Writing history … or “history”

Filed under: Books, Britain, History — Tags: , , — Nicholas @ 03:00

Historiography is difficult, because the people who write histories are not just fallible human beings who make mistakes, but they have all the particular weaknesses and failings of human beings. They might be pushing an agenda, they might be trying to hide their own biases, they may favour “what should have happened” over “what actually happened” … or they could just be lazy. On Substack Notes, Medieval Realms shares an example from last century:

Ancient historians were not limited to mere evidence (not part of Medieval Realms’ original post).

Some of you may have noticed I tend to question popular narratives of medieval battles. I’m not trying to score cheap points, but it is a fact that the evidence often fails to match up. The following is another example.

In November 1294 a series of revolts were raging in Wales. Two battles were supposedly fought, at Denbigh and Builth.

The battle at Builth comes from John Morris, writing circa 1900. He was a grammar school teacher and academic historian, whose best-known work is The Welsh Wars of Edward I. This was the first study to make thorough use of contemporary records held in the Public Record Office.

In his book, Morris wrote:

    John Giffard organised a relieving force of ten knights, twenty troopers and forty light horse, who made five attempts to cut their way through to the castle [at Builth], and were finally successful about November 12.

In his footnotes, Morris quoted the attached document. I recently had this translated. The preamble reads:

    Account of John Giffard, constable of the castle of Builth, of the wages and expenses made by him in the custody of the said castle and in the capture of various rebels and thieves in those parts.

This is followed by a set of expenses, totalling £65 10 shillings 8 pence.

There is no mention of Giffard having to cut his way through Welsh siege lines, or anything so dramatic. He was being paid to garrison Builth and deal with “various rebels and thieves”.

Obviously, it is no easy task to extract medieval documents and compare them to modern accounts. But we should make the effort, where possible.

November 7, 2026

A different kind of neo-colonialism

Filed under: Britain, Bureaucracy, Government, History — Tags: , , , — Nicholas @ 05:00

In The Daily Sceptic, David Betz and Michael Rainsborough point out that the British government, in its dealings with the British public, seems to have fallen back on habits developed in the days of the world-spanning British Empire:

The territories that were at one time or another part of the British Empire. The United Kingdom and its accompanying British Overseas Territories are underlined in red.
Composed by “The Red Hat of Pat Ferrick” via Wikimedia Commons.

Despite spending much of the past half-century apologising for the Empire, the British establishment is rediscovering its favourite method of rule. The old colonial district officer, accustomed to keeping the peace between rival communities, cultivating local notables and reporting troublesome political sentiments to his superiors, would find much to recognise in contemporary Britain. He might struggle with the current terminology, but once someone explained what a Cohesion Support and Interventions Function actually did, he would probably feel quite at home.

In an essay we wrote six years ago called “Empires of Progress“, we argued that Western governing elites were increasingly abandoning the assumptions of the nation-state in favour of an imperial conception of political authority. A nation-state presumes a people sufficiently conscious of belonging together to accept common institutions and obligations. An empire governs different peoples, often possessing competing interests and loyalties, through a combination of accommodation, patronage, arbitration and coercion. Nations require citizens; empires administer subjects.

What we then identified as an emerging tendency has since acquired a more distinct institutional and political character in Britain. Successive governments, having encouraged mass immigration and multiculturalism, increasingly employ methods familiar from imperial administration to manage the communal divisions arising from those policies.

More significantly, these arrangements threaten to transform the relationship between the governing establishment and the historic British population, whose national attachments and political preferences increasingly conflict with the assumptions of those exercising power. Here, we examine how communal brokerage, differentiated accommodation and preventive security contribute to this estrangement, weakening the common national allegiance upon which the legitimacy of the state depends.

The imperial reflex, imported into the British domestic realm, we suggest, will prove considerably more destabilising than its practitioners anticipate.

Divide, rule, cultivate allies

British imperial administration depended upon an intimate knowledge of the populations it governed. Officials classified communities by ethnicity, religion and customary authority, cultivated influential intermediaries and distributed recognition, privileges and patronage to secure cooperation.

Such arrangements reduced the costs of government while giving selected local leaders a stake in the preservation of imperial authority. The British also secured the allegiance of particular populations whose interests became closely associated with the existing political order.

Governing through intermediaries and building dependent constituencies were complementary techniques, although the interests of the two were not always identical. By recognising communal leaders as representatives of distinct populations, imperial administrations could also reinforce the divisions that sustained their authority.

In British Malaya, for example, colonial economic development encouraged large-scale Chinese and Indian immigration, transforming the demographic composition of the peninsula and creating competing communal interests. The colonial economy developed along pronounced ethnic lines, with Malays concentrated in agriculture, Chinese communities prominent in commerce and mining, and Indian labour recruited extensively for plantation work. While not absolute, these divisions established a political landscape in which economic interests and communal identities became closely associated. British administrators also relied upon recognised communal intermediaries, including Chinese leaders known as Kapitan Cina, who mediated relations with Chinese communities and whose commercial privileges and political influence could become closely connected with the colonial power.

After the Second World War, the proposed Malayan Union of 1946 sought to extend citizenship to much of the immigrant-origin population while reducing the authority of the Malay rulers. Malay opposition forced the British to abandon the scheme in favour of the Federation of Malaya in 1948, with more restrictive citizenship provisions. The subsequent establishment of the Communities Liaison Committee in 1949 brought leading Malay, Chinese and Indian representatives together to negotiate questions of citizenship, economic interests and national identity. Political authority rested upon negotiations among recognised communal organisations, culminating in the Alliance between Malay, Chinese and Indian parties that helped secure independence in 1957. The British authorities, in effect, created the demographic and economic circumstances that made communal bargaining an indispensable feature of the constitutional settlement that followed.

At home, the contemporary British state confronts comparable divisions arising from a demographic transformation shaped decisively by the policies of governments of both major parties.

Older Posts »

Powered by WordPress