If you were working on the ground floor, you could play a game with yourself or a like-minded colleague (not a given) where you guessed the type of customer from the moment that they entered the front door. If they were heading to the sci-fi/fantasy section (yes, yes, they’re different) this was not too difficult. Likewise, the true crime corner – the shop being quite close to HMP *REDACTED* – though one was less likely to snigger openly at those people. Within the overwhelmingly dominant fiction floorspace, one would have to make more-particular assessments: colour of jacket (the book, but maybe also the customer), quantity of gold lettering (ditto), ratio of author’s name to title, that sort of thing.
Alas (not really, though), I was generally stationed on the first floor – History, Politics, Philosophy, Music, Poetry – with which my interests were more naturally aligned. This was the haunt of middle-aged men, or wives shopping on middle-aged-men’s behalves. A person sporting cords and flat brown shoes (gender irrelevant) could easily be headed anywhere within the first floor’s offerings.
The one place I would practically beg not to be sent was to the top floor, where there had once been a decent cafe that my mother would take me too, en route to choir or a violin lesson, but where now they kept the children’s books – especially, the ones that, when a small kid touches them, emit a basic, synthesised tune that cannot be silenced or changed, even with heavy objects. Just covering this section for someone’s lunch hour could induce a nasty case of PTSD.
A.S.H. Smyth, “Seven kinds of people you find in bookshops”, The Critic, 2020-11-14.
November 22, 2026
QotD: Working in a bookshop
November 19, 2026
Progressives on Elon Musk – “Sentence first, verdict afterwards”
Once upon a time, long ago in the far distant past of a few years ago, Elon Musk was one of the “good” billionaires according to the progressives. His Tesla electric cars were the vehicles all good leftists wanted to have (except for those purists who wanted nobody to have private vehicles under any circumstances). Then … horrors … he plummeted from progressive heaven to become one of the chief devils in Trump’s hell, and now the people who used to love him want him in prison. They don’t know what crimes he may have committed, but they’ll figure that out after he’s been stripped of his wealth and clad in an orange jumpsuit:
What crime did he commit? Well, Katie Pavlich tried to get a Democrat lawmaker to say, and that went about like you’d expect.
Texas Democratic Rep. Gene Wu found that out when he appeared on NewsNation and tried to explain why billionaire Elon Musk should face criminal prosecution. Host Katie Pavlich asked him to identify an actual crime, and things got awkward fast.
What makes the exchange particularly interesting is that Wu, the minority leader of the Texas House Democrats, is a former felony prosecutor in the Harris County District Attorney’s Office. You would think that identifying a potential criminal offense would come naturally to him.
“Can you give us some of the examples of […] what you think that those things may be? It’s a pretty, pretty extreme charge,” Pavlich asked.
“All I do is read the news and watch the news,” Wu replied. “And what I have seen on the news is that Elon may have committed crimes against the United States by his actions in Ukraine. […] I don’t know. I just read what I read.”
Pavlich wasn’t about to let that answer slide.
Wu then started moving the goalposts, claiming there should be an investigation to see if he committed a crime.
The problem is, that’s not what Wu initially claimed. He claimed there were specific crimes Musk may have committed. Then, when pressed for specific charges, everything fizzled out.
There’s a reason for that.
See, for them, Musk’s actual crime is everything I laid out in yesterday’s post. He undermines everything they claim, and so they despise him. He’s proof that success is possible and that free enterprise is better at pretty much everything than the government ever will be.
Which would be fine if Musk also toed the line like so many other billionaires. He doesn’t, though. He’s not shaking leftist hands and pretending that everything is fine with their hatred for the rich. He’s not playing nice with the Left, who never played nice with him.
So, all that’s happened is that Musk did something they hated more than usual, particularly with regard to Ukraine supposedly misusing Starlink, and decided that now they needed to start a witch hunt.
“Show me the man and I’ll show you the crime,” the Soviet enforcer said, and the Left is still playing by those rules.
November 17, 2026
Life in the EU – “Permission Is the Currency”
Life in the European Union is much more regulated now than even a decade ago, as the bureaucrats promulgate ever more rules to micromanage as much as they can. Naturally, one of the few “growth” industries in the EU are the specialized consultancies to help individuals and companies navigate their way to doing what they want to do. On X, Krzysztof Szczawinski explains:
Permission Is the Currency
In Europe, everything is illegal by default. You want to build, hire, launch? You ask. And if no one answers – that’s a no.
When everything requires permission, permission becomes the currency. And like every currency, it creates its own economy.
A reader who works in finance told me about an invoice that crossed his desk. A client in property rental had paid a consulting firm to help one of his buildings get an EU eco-certificate. They planted some trees. They put bees on the roof. Certificate granted – and with it, better access to EU-linked financing.
Follow the chain. Someone invented the certificate, and got paid for it. Someone founded a consultancy to help you obtain it, and gets paid for it. Someone audits whether you deserve it, and gets paid for it. And finally the owner pays to modify the building so it fits the boxes. Everyone has a job. Everyone has an invoice. GDP goes up.
And nothing was produced. Not one more flat, not a better roof, not a cheaper rent. The bees are not there for honey. They are there for the permission.
This is how the EU’s soft power works. No need to force a law through, with a vote, a debate, a court. Just attach a condition to the money. Follow our recommendations, collect our certificates – or no financing, no subsidies, and you cannot compete with those who did. You are free. Just not funded.
A law you can fight – in court, or at the next election. A condition on money you can only accept, or lose. Power without a signature, without accountability, without anyone to vote out.
The same with universities: research follows the grant, and the grant follows the agenda. The same with cities. We saw it in Polish towns where councillors had to revoke resolutions – “legally meaningless”, they were told – because EU funds were on the line. If it was meaningless, why the threat? Because it was never about the law. It was about who decides.
Now imagine that system combined with post-communist administrative habits.
I don’t have to imagine. I live in Poland.
The people who master a permission economy are the ones who always did: the post-communists and their networks. Forty years of practice in navigating the apparatus did not disappear in 1989. It got a Brussels upgrade. So the connected do anything. For everyone else, everything is illegal, or very, very hard. The system does not select for the best builders. It selects for the best-connected askers – same as before 1989.
Everything is pretend now. Pretend ecology – bees for paperwork. Pretend science – theories that can never be wrong. Pretend self-government – councils that vote until the money disagrees. Pretend work – reports nobody reads, written to satisfy rules nobody needed, checked by people whose job is checking.
Pointless? Not for everyone. It keeps posts. It keeps positions. It keeps the structure of power standing and the people inside it paid. That is its real product. The only thing the system produces efficiently is more of itself. Millions of people dependent on it and committed to keep it standing – until collapse.
And someone pays for all of it. Not Brussels – the tenant, in the rent. The buyer, in the price. The worker, in the tax. Every pretend job is carried on the back of a real one.
Meanwhile a young couple does the maths and stops at two children. Often at one. The building can afford bees on its roof. The family cannot afford a third child under its own.
Meanwhile in the US (except for California I hear), they just build. That is the whole difference. One system asks who you know. The other asks what you can do.
That is what rot looks like. Not collapse – collapse is at least honest. Rot is a structure that still stands, still issues certificates, still hires consultants – green on the outside, increasingly hollow inside.
Everything is pretend now – except the decline. That one is real, and it compounds.
And a compounding decline ends up going pretty quickly…
November 16, 2026
That Fine Line Between Smuggling and Legal Trade: Anecdotes from Val Forgett
Forgotten Weapons
Published 15 Jul 2026Dealing in firearms internationally is a trade scrutinized pretty closely by governments, and its practitioners can often end up acting as agents for government priorities, and also victims of said priorities changing. Val Forgett of Navy Arms grew up with his father doing exactly this sort of thing. Today we have some interesting anecdotes about guns going into Cuba and Lebanon, among others …
(more…)
November 15, 2026
Microsoft’s M365 outage
Millions of people have now experienced the joy of an empty inbox, thanks to the extended outage on one of Microsoft’s most important business software offerings. Many people are saying that Microsoft, having gotten rid of a lot of its veteran engineering staff over the last few years, may not be capable of fixing the problem. On X, John Ringo offers his thoughts:
CAN Microsoft recover?
(This was a reply to something. I decided it was better as a post.)
Oh, I agree. They’ve been getting rid of the nerds that built the system and have this little undocumented bit of knowledge in their heads for years. That is a huge issue and definitely contributing to the downtime.
But they (and AWS and others) have also built a system that is so complex and interwoven, the real issue is:
If it crashes this hard can they bring it back up as it was at all?
We get into discussions of telos and kosmos. It’s distinctly possible if you brought back EVERYONE who built it that they still couldn’t fix Humpty-Dumpty.
We’ll see by Monday.
Telos and kosmos.
Telos is a simple simple system. Every point in the system is understood and is comprehensible by a single person. (A single server. A large but not enormous set of servers.)
Then there are simple complex systems. A system where every individual part of the system can be comprehended but it’s impossible to comprehend how all the parts interact.
That is what Microsoft and AWS and other cloud providers have created. A system where you can maybe understand why this bit isn’t working but not why/how its interacting to cause all these other bits to not work.
It’s too complex.
It’s one of the reasons that the people saying “Nobody is going to migrate off the cloud. Nobody wants to run their own servers. No IT guy wants to run email. These guys are literally the experts.” are all wrong.
When a single company, from a two man shop to fortune 500, uses its own server system, the entire system can be understood. It is telos. Every bit can be comprehended. It may be badly documented. There may be this little “thing” that only Joe Neckbeard knows and if you fire him you may have an outage.
But it’s NOT so big nobody can really rebuild it in a serious meltdown.
Rebuilding this ecosystem is so complex that it’s like nuking Manhattan and expecting every single piece to go back just like magic.
It won’t. And those missing pieces are Gladys’ payroll spreadsheet that she inherited from Gloria who inherited it from Sandra who inherited it from Carol who got some nerd who left in 1996 to do it for her.
The question becomes, what to do if it’s not back by Monday?
November 14, 2026
“Some ideas are so bad that both major political parties support them”
Most Americans think that more “bipartisanship” would be a good thing, yet every time there actually is an issue that both Democrats and Republicans can support … it seems to be a uniquely terrible idea that sounds good but brings awful unintended consequences tumbling along behind:

“Credit Cards” by Sean MacEntee is licensed under CC BY 2.0 .
Even in these divided times, some ideas are so bad that both major political parties support them. That’s certainly the case with proposals to let the government put a cap on the interest rates charged by credit card companies. It’s a scheme that seems considerate to those who run up debt but would instead deny riskier borrowers access to legitimate credit, and it could drive many people to lenders — some underground — who charge more. That is, it’s a plan stupid enough to draw backing from Democrats and Republicans alike.
Bipartisan Economic Idiocy
“President Trump himself said that he wants to reduce interest rates on credit cards to 10 percent,” Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D–Mass.) told CBS’s Margaret Brennan on Sunday. “I got the bill, I’m ready to go.”
Sure enough, back in January, President Donald Trump posted on Truth Social, “Please be informed that we will no longer let the American Public be ‘ripped off’ by Credit Card Companies that are charging Interest Rates of 20 to 30%, and even more … Effective January 20, 2026, I, as President of the United States, am calling for a one year cap on Credit Card Interest Rates of 10%.”
The two nominally hostile politicians discussed cooperation on the issue earlier this year, though nothing concrete has come of it so far. It’s enough to make you wonder if the issue is enough to bridge political divides for these two as they flirt over their shared interest in idiotic economic populism.
And the idea of capping credit card interest rates really is idiotic, unless you’re trying to deny options to higher-risk borrowers and drive them to more expensive alternatives like payday lenders and loan sharks. We don’t have to speculate on the impact of such caps; there’s plenty of evidence that trying to forcibly lower borrowing costs for consumers cuts them off from legitimate credit.
In 2021, the Federal Reserve Board published a paper by Gregory Elliehausen, Simona M. Hannon, and Thomas W. Miller Jr., examining the impact of a 17 percent interest rate cap in Arkansas. They found that “consumer finance companies, traditionally a source of credit for nonprime consumers, do not have offices in Arkansas because, being subject to the usury ceiling, they cannot profitably lend to risky consumers.” Because of its impact on riskier borrowers, the cap was loosened for banks to “allow consumers to escape restrictive effects of the low Arkansas rate ceiling.” Even so, “results of our analysis suggest that nonprime consumers in Arkansas were rationed” in terms of access to credit.
Notably, the paper described the 17 percent cap as “very restrictive.” The 10 percent cap currently contemplated by politicians of both major parties would be that much tighter and could be anticipated to further restrict access to credit.
The Stellantis Brampton plant became an unforced political error for Carney
The Stellantis (formerly Chrysler) auto manufacturing plant in Brampton, Ontario has been idle for a few years. Brokering a deal to sell the plant to Roshel, who manufacture armoured vehicles for domestic and foreign militaries, would seem to be a no-brainer for the federal government: renewed economic activity in Brampton, up-and-coming Canadian manufacturer expands production, and Stellantis gets rid of a facility they no longer need. Wins all around. What could possibly go wrong?
I heard someone say on CBC on Thursday that Stellantis is the weakest of the auto companies. That’s been true for decades. Previously known in North America as Chrysler, the company has had bailout after bailout.
Stellantis has been in the news of late for its decision to sell its Brampton auto assembly plant to defence firm Roshel.
The Brampton plant was announced as a project of American Motors Corporation in 1984 and opened in 1986. Despite the name, American Motors Corporation was controlled by Renault in France, and the company was having trouble.
In 1987, American Motors Corporation was purchased by Chrysler.
As much as I have loved many Chrysler products over the years, from my first car, a 1984 Dodge Omni, to a Chrysler LeBaron my grandparents gave me, to a great Caravan that carted around my kids, Chrysler, and American Motors before it, were always the sick car companies on the block.
I give you this background to explain that this plant has long been on the brink.
For the past several years, I’ve had politicians and auto executives push back on that idea, but I’ve known people who have been working in that plant on and off — far too often off — since the 1990s.
Could the Carney government have done something to try to save this plant?
Sure, they absolutely could have, but Carney doesn’t want to. He wants to call what Stellantis is doing a betrayal. He wants to pick a proxy fight with European-owned Stellantis by making it about Trump.
All that said, the surest way to bring this plant back would have been to try to strike a deal with the Americans. As I wrote in the Toronto Sun today, that was not in the cards for Mark Carney, who doesn’t want to score a deal if it will hurt him politically.
He chooses politics over economics time and again. Strange, considering he’s an economist and former central bank governor.
I was certain that the Brampton AMC plant had been there long before 1984, as I’d passed an AMC-branded factory many times when I lived in Mississauga before 1982, but it turns out that I was thinking of a different location, AMC’s Brampton Assembly plant.
On X, Martyupnorth comments on the situation:
Stellantis just sold the Brampton plant. After years of idling, after Ottawa threw hundreds of millions at them in 2022, after the production they promised got moved to Illinois the moment tariffs made Canada less competitive. It’s not like they didn’t try. They gave up.
This is what happens when you run a country on ideology instead of reality. High taxes, endless red tape, energy policy that makes everything more expensive, and then you act shocked when companies pack up and leave. Browbeating foreign investors, as this guest mentions, and threatening lawsuits after the fact doesn’t fix the underlying problem. It just tells the next company: don’t bother coming here.
Canada is not an attractive place to do business right now. The numbers keep proving it. The Trudeau-Singh Liberals (and now Carney) keep doubling down on the same approach that got us here … more subsidies, more threats, more speeches about “betrayal” … while the real message to investors is clear … “Stay away”.
Where’s Doug Ford in all this? Ontario put money on the table too. He can talk about protecting jobs all he wants, but the plant is gone. Reality doesn’t care about the press conference.
Ideology keeps losing. Reality always wins. The question is how much more of the auto sector, and how many more jobs, have to disappear before enough Canadians finally wake up to this?
My real fear is that Carney will execute the plan he had all along, and nationalize another industry. He’ll step in and buy the factory. That’s not a win, that’s an even bigger loss.
To the Liberals in Ottawa, appearances matter so much more than reality, and the idiocy around the plant sale demonstrates that again:
November 13, 2026
QotD: Occupational licensing, regulation and economic slowdown
One of the most egregious ways that government favors insiders is occupational licensing, typically presented as a way to protect consumers. Economists Morris Kleiner and Alan Krueger documented that, in the late 1950s, less than five percent of American workers needed some form of occupational license. Licensing in fields with a real public-health impact — pharmacy, say — may protect some consumers, but it’s hard to see why the person selling you flowers or your eyeglass frames needs certification.
Licensing can deter someone from starting a new job or experimenting with new occupations. If you think that you might like to be a florist, you could just try it out, in a free environment. If floristry requires a long process of certification, though, you’re more likely to stick with your current job. Occupational licensing also makes it harder to move across states to seek work, since licensing requirements vary.
[…]
Government rules also deter job creation by mandating extensive employee benefits. The most obvious costs come from Social Security, workers’ compensation, and Medicare, which cumulatively average $2.85 per hour — increasing the effective hourly minimum wage from $7.25 to more than $10. The Fair Labor Standards Act also requires overtime pay for nonexempt workers. Other rules have made it easier for workers to sue their employers, adding a further potential cost to hiring.
Individual states and localities impose rules that drive up employment costs, too, such as Oregon’s $12 minimum wage or the $16 minimum wage in Seattle. The national minimum remains too low typically to have much impact on older workers, but it does matter for the employment prospects of younger workers with fewer skills. Economist Jeffrey Clemens found that Congress’s 2007–09 increases in the national minimum wage decreased the probability of being employed by about 5 percentage points for workers between the ages of 16 and 30 who lacked a high school diploma, in states that had previously kept their minimums low. In other research, Clemens and Michael Wither found that minimum-wage hikes led to similarly substantial reductions in the probability that minimum-wage workers would rise to monthly earnings levels over $1,500.
Edward L. Glaeser, “How to Fix American Capitalism”, City Journal, 2020-12-13.
November 9, 2026
The looming end of secure encryption
Secure encryption is one of those background utilities we all depend on, like plumbing and sewers: it only comes to our attention when something is going wrong. David Clinton says that things are going wrong with encryption standards, thanks to the technical omnicause, artificial intelligence:
This topic has a guaranteed boredom score of 12 (where “10” represents catatonic). But its could make a difference to my own life score is 15 (where “10” represents “Yikes!”).
Data encryption is the peg on which the possibility of all modern financial and healthcare-related activity hangs. Without standard encryption algorithms like AES and RSA:
- The contents of every exchange of information between you and your bank’s website would be visible to anyone on the internet.
- The passwords you use to authenticate to your digital accounts would be readable by anyone with access to any node between you and your account’s host.
- The sensitive data stored by any financial, healthcare, or government organization would be visible to anyone with access to their host systems — access made possible by decrypted passwords (see above).
Encrypted data contains all the original information. But its value lies in the assumption that the underlying algorithm is so complex that it would require the use of powerful computers and hundreds of years to crack it.
For the past 50 years, that assumption has held up well. But the theoretical existence of quantum compute resources — which can execute exponentially more compute operations than traditional processors — presents a theoretical threat to existing algorithms.
In other words sometime within the next 10-20 years, quantum compute devices will be powerful enough to brute-force the end of modern encryption. That sounds scary.
But it’s arguably not even the real problem. That, as Tyler Cowan recently wrote in the Free Press, would be the recent explosion of AI-driven discoveries in mathematics. Such events have introduced concerns about the odds encryption security could be compromised in months rather than years.
Frontier AI models are now at least making progress solving longstanding mathematical problems. The pace of discovery seems to be growing and it seems inevitable that someone somewhere will turn a powerful AI model on the algorithms we rely on.
November 7, 2026
QotD: “Capital allocators” and “operators”
If you hang out much with finance bros (or “capital allocators” as they now call themselves),1 you may chance to hear somebody described as an “operator”. What is this strange species? What is this unusual job with an unusual title? Near as I can tell, an “operator” is somebody who actually runs a real business in the real world. But atop the commanding heights of 21st century America, that makes you an anomaly. You have no podcast. You have no portfolio of bets. You have no LPs, no byzantine leverage structure, and no IRR calculations. You don’t flit from deal to deal, hovering on a castle of financialized abstractions so ethereal the lack of air pressure at that altitude gives you a nosebleed. You aren’t even an intellectual or a scribbler who writes about real things at a layer of remove. No, instead you toil in the muck, doing basically the same thing every day, trying to make an actual business actually succeed. What a weirdo.
John Psmith, “REVIEW: Anabasis, by Xenophon”, Mr. and Mrs. Psmith’s Bookshelf, 2026-06-01.
- This neologism is actually incredible It’s like something out of early 20th century Marxist propaganda, but they did it to themselves! This is not helping us beat the accusation that we live in a cleverly-disguised planned economy.
November 5, 2026
“Machine-tooled emotional manipulation: how a department-store Christmas ad should be”
John Lewis, the British department store with a history of heart-warming (if saccharine) Christmas ads released there their 2026 Christmas ad and … it’s getting a lot of attention, but not the kind of attention the company may have anticipated:
[Previous John Lewis Christmas ads have] often been rather sweet with an agreeable, universal sentiment. Missing friends, shyness, loneliness, not wanting to leave people out, etc. Hibernating bears. Machine-tooled emotional manipulation. Which is how a department-store Christmas ad should be.
This year, however, they’ve assumed we’ll be enchanted by rude, selfish, misbehaving children whose affection has to be bought with great effort and at great expense, in desperation. And the decision to make those children brown – because apparently you can’t have an advert without the statistically unlikely interracial couple – adds a dynamic that I somehow doubt was intended.
Commenter [+] quips,
They’ve accidentally made a Restore Britain campaign video.
What’s remarkable is that the project must have involved any number of highly-paid, supposedly clued-up experts, masters of nuance, and endless meetings, over months … and no bugger spotted how readily the ad lends itself to much less festive interpretations.
I watched it again this morning and am still processing just how weirdly misjudged it is.
For instance, that heartwarming moment when the scowling, diverse grandchildren shake their Christmas cards in annoyance, having found no money in them. Behaviour enabled, one assumes, by the ineffectual, unapologetic parents, who allow their offspring to wreck other people’s homes and to jump up and down on other people’s furniture.
And remember, we’re supposed to like these unparented brats, enough to care about pleasing them. And we’re supposed to identify with the grandma who wants these brats to love her, if only for a few minutes, before they presumably resume their scowling, ungrateful ways.
Feel that Christmas spirit, people.
November 3, 2026
QotD: Human Resources
Humans cannot be reduced to objects, as Kant proclaimed. Or, more exactly, they should not be. Still, as I approach the man, I slip on a patch of black ice, named David Hume.
A large part of the power tussle everywhere, might be captioned, “The victory of transhumanism”.
Or, to put it in more preposterous form: “The Final Solution of HR”.
For departments of human resources state the transhumanist position baldly. They declare that humans are resources, like oil and gas, or pork bellies. Or, robots. Humans can be used — or discarded — by a cost-benefit analysis. If a human can do something cheaper than a robot, then very well, we’ll continue to pay him. But if the robot can do it cheaper, then the human has to go.
There is a practical problem, getting rid of him, but they have a plan for that in Human Resources.
David Warren, “One last harrumph for Trumph”, Essays in Idleness, 2021-01-16.
November 2, 2026
High-trust minority populations have huge advantages in low-trust communities
But on the flip side, those advantages can raise resentment against the minority if their social and economic position improves too obviously against that of the communities they inhabit. Lorenzo Warby finishes his short series of essays on the Marxist labels of “capitalism” and “capitalist”:
For another example of what dreadful terms capitalism and capitalist are, consider market-dominant minorities such as overseas Chinese (particularly Hakka), overseas Indians (particularly Gujaratis), overseas Lebanese (particularly Maronites), Jews, Igbos, the Sogdian diaspora … These are groups with strong internal trust and reputation networks that give them strong information — and so coordinating, anticipation and risk-management — advantages over people in the wider society. This is especially true in low-trust societies. Such market-dominant minorities have advantages in engaging in commerce and in creating and using capital.
Capital is not magical. It does not spontaneously arise or get used well. It has to be created and applied. Not only that, it is very clear that groups and polities vary greatly in their capacity to create and use capital. It is that — highly variable — creation and use that is crucial.
Capital has to be coordinated; it has to be used in service of sufficiently correct anticipation of commercial and other conditions; there has to be risk management. These things are all information and feedback questions.
Market-dominant minorities are so because of their advantages in information and feedback — including how they use that information and feedback. (If I wanted to summarise problems with contemporary Western democracies in a single phrase, it would be broken feedbacks.)
It turns out, that their human and social capital and their culture — that is, their norms, skills, outlooks and connections — are the real advantages of market-dominant minorities. None of these features are mere products of capital; not even those that count as capital.
Nor is this capital that you can just add from outside. They cannot be readily incorporated into some arithmetic function of labour and capital (such as a Cobb-Douglas production function). Since these features are so much about human agency, and information and normative landscapes, it is a open question whether calling human and social capital forms of capital is, in itself, misleading.
Part of the problem for market-dominant minorities is precisely that their use of information is “invisible” to outsiders. (It is also invisible to Marxist Theory.) It is thus easy to accuse them of “cheating”, of being “social parasites”.
As history shows again and again, convince a group of Homo sapiens that that group over there are parasites — and that you and yours would be better off without them — and one has set the scene for massacre, for mass murder. A principle that the entire history of Revolutionary Marxism, of Communism, displays even more vividly: every single Marxist mass murder was legitimated by the parasites charge. This is why the labour theory of value is a primer for mass murder.
Communism has been so murderous because it labels entire classes as parasites. Nazism was so murderous because it labelled entire races as parasites—indeed, also as toxic, exploitive parasites—and created a realm of destroyed states that stripped people of the protections of citizenship: regions where Nazi race extermination was more deadly to the population than even Stalinism. In both cases, creating the golden future required eliminating the human blocks to the same.
In the case of market-dominant minorities, the very interior clannishness that gives them information, reputation and feedback—so trust—advantages can also lead to genuinely exploitive behaviour towards outsiders. Periodic massacres and expulsions of market-dominant minorities is a pattern going back many centuries, across states and civilisations. (China provides some dramatic examples, while Chinese diasporas have also been victims of such.)
Those strong internal connections within market-dominant minorities can be very much a two-edged sword. Whatever role capital plays in all this, it is very much derivative of the underlying dynamics of human action: especially of information and normative landscapes.
November 1, 2026
“Welcome to the wonderful world of carbon accounting”
One of the biggest blind spots for climate warriors is the proportion of hand-waving and wishful thinking required to make their grand unified visions of a Net Zero world, as revealed by John Robson as he conducts the search for the fabled “Scope 3”:
We recently got an email from Heatmap saying “Half of companies with net-zero commitments call scope 3 their biggest barrier.” And we thought duh what? And then “Probably the other half said ‘What’s scope 3?'” It turns out to be the carbon emissions you don’t emit but get blamed for anyway. More fun from the wacky world of climate economics. Which has this regrettable feature in common with interventionist economics generally: They don’t know enough to know what they don’t know. The email also said “Most are stuck on spend-based estimates too rough to prove whether their reduction programs are working”. As in the old Soviet Union the planners basically planned to spend because unless you let consumer preferences form prices in competitive markets, you can’t tell whether you’re making something useful or just sawdust sausages and ill-fitting size 12 shoes all for left feet.
In a striking departure from modern journalistic practice, we responded by Googling “Scope 3”. And it turns out to be something very revealing in its unrevealingness. For instance, from the “Carbon Trust“:
The Greenhouse Gas Protocol – which provides the most widely recognised accounting standards for greenhouse gas emissions – categorises GHG emissions into three ‘scopes’. Scope 1 covers direct emissions from owned or controlled sources. Scope 2 covers indirect emissions from the purchase and use of electricity, steam, heating and cooling. By using the energy, an organisation is indirectly responsible for the release of these GHG emissions. Scope 3 includes all other indirect emissions that occur in the upstream and downstream activities of an organisation.
So here’s the problem. Scope 1 is reasonably easy to measure, at least in principle. It’s the GHGs you emit directly by doing whatever you’re doing, minus presumably staff breathing out CO2 while at work. Scope 2 isn’t too bad: it’s the same as Scope 1 except it’s from your power suppliers for whatever share of their output you acquire. But Scope 3 is a very different beast. It’s all the emissions from all the people you bought stuff from, plus all the emissions from all the people who bought your products. All of them. Every single one. Even your kid’s lemonade stand. And all based on pseudo-scientific “accounting and reporting standards” that sound good, make work, generate money and are no use in the real world.
Here we must again cite Leonard Read’s 1958 classic “I, Pencil“, a demonstration even from a simpler era when people used pencils not AI that tracing out all the steps involved in making things, was inherently a transcomputable and never-ending quest. Thus, the pencil tells the reader, “not a single person on the face of this earth knows how to make me”. Take any part of it: the wood, the paint, the eraser, the graphite, and you touch a global supply chain of near infinite complexity. Among a great many other things, that:
My bit of metal – the ferrule – is brass. Think of all the persons who mine zinc and copper and those who have the skills to make shiny sheet brass from these products of nature. Those black rings on my ferrule are black nickel. What is black nickel and how is it applied? The complete story of why the center of my ferrule has no black nickel on it would take pages to explain.
And to explain who made the coffee and shoes and razor blades for the miners, and who produced the fuel for the ships that carried these goods about, and who made the machine tools to create sheet brass, and on and on, would defy any central planner even before they got to the problem that all these people in turn used pencils (we said it was 1958). Which is why after an initial burst of idealism Soviet Five-Year Plans were essentially reduced to replicating last year’s plan and adding a few percent.
Now imagine trying to track all the carbon emissions. Because it’s what Scope 3 aims to do as if it were a mere detail.
Incidentally Soviet planners from the 1960s on into the 1980s actually thought that more powerful computers would overcome this problem, being unclear on the concept of “transcomputable” particularly as it applied to systems with feedback loops. Then the USSR done died. But not this hope.
Thus Heatmap insists that it can be done with their handy guide, which “lays out a four-step playbook for closing the gap between scope 3 commitments and measurable supply chain progress, using domain-specialized sustainability AI” and from whose three “What you’ll learn” gems the first is:
How to move from spend-based estimates to product-level emissions data in hours – with AI-powered material mapping and multi-agent validation
Oooh. AI-powered. Domain-specialized no less. And multi-agent validation. We suppose it beats getting it all from Agent 86. But not by much because the fantasy of measuring all the carbon outputs from all your inputs relies on the fantasy of measuring all your inputs and you can’t.
In a market economy, a real one, you don’t have to. As Read also said, as long as you know the price you must pay for the immediate inputs, how to assemble them into outputs, and the price you can get for those outputs, you can tell whether a purchase is rational. But if you have to know more than you can, you’re sunk. Especially if you don’t know you can’t.
Welcome to the wonderful world of carbon accounting. Do not mistake it for the real kind of accounting though.

















