Quotulatiousness

November 19, 2026

Books? How old-fashioned

Filed under: Books, Health, Media, Technology — Tags: , , , — Nicholas @ 05:00

I’ve been noticing more and more when I’m forced to sit in a waiting room that I’m often the only person actually reading a physical book … some are distracted by the omnipresent TV screens (usually with the sound off, thank goodness, but not always) but most are staring into their pocket molochs, the wrecktangles. Books are becoming less and less a part of peoples’ daily lives, including the time children spend in school. James Pew implores us to return to books for our own sakes:

Books are the answer.

    (Books) are no longer an important part of the lives of students. “Information” is important, but profound and beautiful books are not where they go for it. They have no books that are companions and friends to which they look for counsel, companionship, inspiration, or pleasure. They do not expect to find in them sympathy for, or clarification of, their inmost desires and experiences.
    — Allan Bloom, The Closing of the American Mind (1987).

Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears. At the precise moment in which I write these words, all are implicated, the lot of us, complicit in scandalous folly of inestimable proportions. We have gone, nay we have slid downward, fallen away from a worthy and self-actualizing path, into an abysmally irrational state hostile to the enlightenment reason which guided our extraordinary age of progress for so many generations. We have turned so completely to the new media — and inward where it directs us — to the new technologies that display video and connect users through cyber worlds. This turning has engendered a post-literate condition, where each and practically every person plays a role but sadly pays a hefty price for their wayward participation.

The antidote is quite simple, and I beg you: Turn back to books.

A literary revival is what is needed more than anything. The reasons for this are many and worth arguing for over several essays where key planks can be expounded, on a general thesis of the existential import of literacy, which should be understood as something far beyond the ability to decipher words or master grammar, but a higher order which in part trains one’s mind to grapple with complex ideas, while accustoming it to modes of introspection and examination involving a myriad of phenomena plucked from human affairs, such as moral puzzles, ambiguities or contradictions. Along with the near infinite variety of things encountered throughout the spectrum of good and evil, that kaleidoscopic tapestry of human condition. But alas, have you noticed how cold young people have become?

But the shelves of the libraries and bookstores found in our communities still hold the greatest stories of the grandest wonders, the bravest heroes, the most eloquent feats of chivalry, full of romance and adventure and mystery and tragedy and magic. My friends, my friends, why hast thou forsaken books? What madness have we wrought upon ourselves? We have turned from deeply thoughtful, to comparatively thoughtless. There was a time, within the broad container of this modern period, where we regularly explored the depths, but today our digital lives barely tempt us to skim the surface. The media mediates us, reduces us, and sidelines our most complex and nuanced human aspects, where the sublime mystery of it all once energized common everyday ponderings wrapped up and smeared with the stuff that dreams were made of. There was eloquence and astonishment and miracles. Where have they gone?

We have been distracted into shallowness at the concurrent moment when relentless suggestion and over-stimulation pushed and prodded us to emotional states impervious to rational modes of being. We transformed into feelings creatures who inherited magical realms from thinking creatures who once had the audacity not just to dream and conceive of those enchanted realms, but to actually construct them.

Literature, for all its fantasy and thaumaturgy, when it pervades a society, creates a state essentially of reified magic. A resplendent sorcery casting spells somehow as capable of transferring the stores of civilization, as of delighting and dazzling those who receive it. There is no high tech modern society that did not emerge from a sophisticated literate one. It is not enough that books still exist, that the geniuses of tomorrow will find them and devour them. It is a general democratized condition of high literacy we are after. This is what will most harness and unleash the potential creative energies found within each person. The mind must ripen through literacy, and high forms of it, damn it — I must not stop repeating this! In developing craniums, latent creative forces must be unlocked, nurtured, and fed with the stories of mankind. The books of myth and fairy tales are the most important books in the elementary school library, and this should be obvious. I don’t think it is. It would be in a society where print literacy was the dominant medium.

Progressives on Elon Musk – “Sentence first, verdict afterwards”

Filed under: Business, Media, Politics, USA — Tags: , , , — Nicholas @ 04:00

Once upon a time, long ago in the far distant past of a few years ago, Elon Musk was one of the “good” billionaires according to the progressives. His Tesla electric cars were the vehicles all good leftists wanted to have (except for those purists who wanted nobody to have private vehicles under any circumstances). Then … horrors … he plummeted from progressive heaven to become one of the chief devils in Trump’s hell, and now the people who used to love him want him in prison. They don’t know what crimes he may have committed, but they’ll figure that out after he’s been stripped of his wealth and clad in an orange jumpsuit:

Trump, Vance, and Musk as America’s Triumvirate – Grok

What crime did he commit? Well, Katie Pavlich tried to get a Democrat lawmaker to say, and that went about like you’d expect.

    Texas Democratic Rep. Gene Wu found that out when he appeared on NewsNation and tried to explain why billionaire Elon Musk should face criminal prosecution. Host Katie Pavlich asked him to identify an actual crime, and things got awkward fast.

    What makes the exchange particularly interesting is that Wu, the minority leader of the Texas House Democrats, is a former felony prosecutor in the Harris County District Attorney’s Office. You would think that identifying a potential criminal offense would come naturally to him.

    “Can you give us some of the examples of […] what you think that those things may be? It’s a pretty, pretty extreme charge,” Pavlich asked.

    “All I do is read the news and watch the news,” Wu replied. “And what I have seen on the news is that Elon may have committed crimes against the United States by his actions in Ukraine. […] I don’t know. I just read what I read.”

    Pavlich wasn’t about to let that answer slide.

Wu then started moving the goalposts, claiming there should be an investigation to see if he committed a crime.

The problem is, that’s not what Wu initially claimed. He claimed there were specific crimes Musk may have committed. Then, when pressed for specific charges, everything fizzled out.

There’s a reason for that.

See, for them, Musk’s actual crime is everything I laid out in yesterday’s post. He undermines everything they claim, and so they despise him. He’s proof that success is possible and that free enterprise is better at pretty much everything than the government ever will be.

Which would be fine if Musk also toed the line like so many other billionaires. He doesn’t, though. He’s not shaking leftist hands and pretending that everything is fine with their hatred for the rich. He’s not playing nice with the Left, who never played nice with him.

So, all that’s happened is that Musk did something they hated more than usual, particularly with regard to Ukraine supposedly misusing Starlink, and decided that now they needed to start a witch hunt.

“Show me the man and I’ll show you the crime,” the Soviet enforcer said, and the Left is still playing by those rules.

November 18, 2026

Winning: “Democrats believe they’ve found an odd secret sauce to holding power: focus on hot-button issues where they’re guaranteed to alienate much of the population”

Filed under: Education, Liberty, Media, Politics, USA, Weapons — Tags: , , , , — Nicholas @ 05:00

Conservatives are still trying to recover from the shock of the US midterm election results, but the Democrats have hit on a sure-fire winner to solidify their support for the next Presidential election campaign:

Just weeks after winning midterm elections in which both major parties were wildly unpopular, but voters were especially angry at Republicans over economic concerns and corruption, Democrats believe they’ve found an odd secret sauce to holding power: focus on hot-button issues where they’re guaranteed to alienate much of the population. I’ve already written about the donkey party’s renewed attacks on school choice, but its partisans are also coming after self-defense rights.

Americans Voted on Economics and Corruption

In the aftermath of the midterms, NBC News polling found “many voters said they viewed the midterm election as a rebuke of President Donald Trump’s performance”. Pollsters reported “an overwhelming majority said the economy is in rough shape (75%)” and that “government corruption was also a key issue”, though voters split over which party can be trusted to fight it. In fact, majorities expressed unfavorable views of both the Democratic Party (53 percent) and Republican Party (59 percent).

This was an election in which Republicans were rejected, and Democrats were selected by default as the maybe-less-bad option. There was no embrace of any agenda, just hope that fresh faces in office would address public worries over dollars, cents, and self-dealing.

Of course, Democrats immediately went on the warpath against school choice. Given the broad popularity of education options with the public, that’s certainly a bold decision, and one indicating freedom-averse public teachers’ unions rank higher than voters in donkey party esteem.

Democrats Ignore Voters To Emphasize Their Anti-Gun Obsessions

Also interesting is Democrats’ decision to revive their efforts to disarm Americans at a time when AP–NORC finds that “few voters (11%) listed ‘guns’ as a top three issue motivating their vote this cycle”. There aren’t many topics more contentious than the rules around weapon ownership and use. Nor is there any issue that’s more clearly being resolved by public action rather than by legislation and debate; owning and carrying firearms have become increasingly popular with an ever-broadening share of the population. Going after guns is guaranteed to anger a lot of voters Democrats need to remain in office.

And yet, many members of the newly (briefly?) ascendant party are doing just that.

“Emboldened by their unexpected majority in the Texas House of Representatives after the 2026 midterm election, Democratic lawmakers have introduced a spate of bills aiming to curb gun rights in the Lone Star State”, reports Stephan Kapustka of The Texan. Proposed restrictions include a “red flag” law that would allow judges to deprive people of firearms without due process, making it a felony for those aged 18–21 to purchase semiautomatic rifles, and unenforceable mandatory background checks on private firearm sales. Proposals also include rules about storage of firearms and a backdoor gun registry.

The Smartphone plague – seduced by the shiny wrecktangle

Filed under: Media, Technology — Tags: , — Nicholas @ 03:00

On Substack, Spaceman Spiff urges us to break our dependence on the omnipresent smartphone … or as he refers to it, “the wrecktangle”:

Many are entranced with the smartphone. An always there, always-on toy with endless fun things to do.

Phone zombies are everywhere, holding their device in their hands, unable to let go, like drugged toddlers.

We know what this is doing to people. We are aware it is being exploited by big business and social engineers.

Humanity is being diminished, one dopamine hit at a time.

The effect of smartphone dependency

It is no secret the smartphone has changed the world because it has changed people.

The most obvious effect of excessive phone use is the shortening of attention spans. Constant scrolling and jumping between exciting content channels is damaging our ability to focus.

Everything is on demand whenever we want. We no longer have to wait for anything, and increasingly we lack the capacity to wait at all.

Learned impatience makes complex tasks requiring sustained attention difficult to accomplish.

This creates a feedback loop that destroys how our brains manage rewards. We expect instant hits. Over time the process speeds up, we need rewards at ever faster frequencies.

Algorithms trap us in echo chambers of our own making. Apps providing content deliver more of what we click on. We barely see alternative views. Any notion of a bigger picture is quickly lost.

This distorts perception. We can become convinced fringe views are normal, so anything outside this becomes extreme no matter how banal.

More generally we forget living through screens is not living at all. Watching the riot unfold on a phone feels real, but is safe. Its destructiveness is softened. Much can be edited out of the footage to soften its impact.

This is true of everything. Screen life is a facsimile of real life, close enough to rob us of living the full experience we are designed for while delivering thrills that mimic the highlights.

Young men get hits from playing computer games, but while sitting in an armchair inside a house instead of in trenches surrounded by mud or real danger. Women get their drama and gossip from reality TV and social media, but in the end are investing in strangers making money.

The artificiality is overlooked when it is still exciting, but is always there in the background, eroding our real lives.

The destroyed reward centres make for a life similar to a junkie. Lots of little hits are chased until nothing works and normal life becomes unbearable in its banality. Life’s possibilities are buried under a mountain of effort you are no longer capable of.

Our present existence is fleeting. None of us have time for this self-abuse.

November 17, 2026

Saint Greta the Apostate

Filed under: Germany, Media, Politics — Tags: , , , , — Nicholas @ 04:00

The damage control began immediately, but the clip of Greta Thunberg laughing her head off to hear that the activists in her original climate change grift were still busy protesting, long after she’d moved on to the Palestine grift went viral. eugyppius has more:

Your eyes have not deceived you. That is indeed the erstwhile how-dare-you climate scolder Greta Thunberg laughing at all the rubes still marching in the Fridays for Future demonstrations she helped found just eight short years ago. “Really? They still do that?” Her scorn bleeds through the screen. Leftist street activism is a fashion-forward undertaking and there’s nothing more pathetic than the clueless dunces still stuck on yesterday’s thing.

Some have asked whether Thunberg’s statements have been taken out of context or otherwise deceptively edited. They have not, and in fact anyone who has followed this strange woman’s activities in the years since 2023 will find nothing surprising about her attitude. After the above clip made the rounds, Thunberg took to Instagram to double-down on her scorn for the bumbling middle-class German racists still marching against carbon emissions on Friday afternoons in Berlin:

The source of this clip is On Tanks into the Climate Crisis – a crowdfunded YouTube documentary by the German activist Hubertus Koch which explores the collapse of climatism in Germany – or, as Koch himself puts it, how “the climate movement got fucked”. In 2019 St. Greta was leading students in worldwide Friday marches against carbon dioxide, in 2021 the Greens rode the wave of climate activism straight into government, but by 2023 their momentum was gone. The energy crisis brought on by the Ukraine war sapped public enthusiasm for self-imposed energy scarcity, the resurgence of the Palestinian cause peeled off many key activists including Thunberg herself, far more effective Covid propaganda left climatist messaging seeming lame and tired and aggressive Green climate policies imposed by Olaf Scholz’s traffic light coalition genuinely terrified millions of voters. All of that played a role, and other things did too.

Thunberg’s impatience with climate-centred activism is apparent throughout her interview with Koch. A big problem is that climate messaging has been mainstreamed and is therefore boring to her. She says that “you are not an activist” if you “actively choose to stay within the playfield of what is mainstream” – then you’re only “an influencer trying to get attention”.

QotD: The French experience of the #MeToo phenomenon

Filed under: France, History, Media, Politics, Quotations — Tags: , , — Nicholas @ 01:00

I initially looked upon #MeToo as a positive, since punishing sexual degenerates is good (if they’re not me). But it quickly devolved into pure mob violence and scapegoating. As it went on and the mob came after men who were clearly just awkward fumblers rather than predators, it did powerfully highlight that progressives are utterly incapable of understanding human sexuality at any level. No wonder they’re so miserable and angry all the time.

Re: France, that’s a good question, and one which I wonder about. Surely a big factor is that we have Strong Libel Laws(tm); the woman who started the French version of the #MeToo hashtag later lost a defamation lawsuit over it. With regard to gender roles, it’s strange, and I’m not sure I have a good explanation for it. There’s something to the idea that we’re feminist in the streets and trads in the sheets. Officially, French people proclaim adherence to a rigid de Beauvoir-style feminism and yet culturally we seem to be, certainly, more Mediterranean. The relationship of French culture to Woman has been unique since the beginning: our fabliaux invented romantic love (CS Lewis’ The Allegory of Love is a good English-language read on this), and then of course later we invented courtly love. Women had a more prominent social role in French culture throughout the Medieval and Early Modern era, commented upon by foreigners. Not many people know that the French Revolution was essentially a misogynistic reaction against the perceived feminization of the Royal Court (recall the abuse hurled at Marie-Antoinette), and that Napoleon’s Civil Code was a major step backward for women’s legal rights. The French Revolution was also an Anglophile and bourgeois (but I repeat myself) movement, which also tried to import the mercantile/Calvinist rigidity of gender relationships.

There’s a line in Flaubert’s “Three Tales”, writing about a peasant girl, which goes something like “She had seen the animals in the fields; she was not innocent in the way of our mademoiselles“. That 19th century French bourgeois parents felt the need to imitate Victorian Brits in shielding their daughters from the basic facts of life is alien to French culture, as surely everyone knows. Maybe part of the bitterness and extremism of 20th century French feminism is a reaction to this Anglo-Puritan importation.

#MeToo could or should have been a helpful wake-up call to the fact that liberal sexual norms just create a wider field for exploitation, but clearly that hasn’t happened. Our only hope now is for men to stop being losers, quit porn, and lift weights. I firmly believe that the cause of our derangement is that men have become losers.

Niccolo Soldo, “The Zürich Interviews – Pascal-Emmanuel Gobry: Unrepentant Baguette Merchant”, Fisted by Foucault, 2020-12-02.

November 16, 2026

“Linguistic cleansing”

Filed under: Government, Media, Politics — Tags: , , , , — Nicholas @ 03:00

On Substack, Frank Furedi discusses the urge to police the language by the media and the powers-that-be to regulate and direct how certain topics are discussed:

Suddenly we are told that instead of using the term illegal immigrant we should refer foreign national who cross our border without official government authorisation as an undocumented immigrant. We are constantly harassed to use gender neutral terms like parent or guardian rather than mother and father.

The top-down project of dispossessing people of their taken-for-granted vocabulary is often justified on the ground that it aims to promote an inclusive language that rids society of words that are offensive to some people. However, when you examine the increasingly long list of terms that are targeted by the proponents of linguistic cleansing, they touch upon words that are not at all insulting. Words like female, mother, father, pregnant women, breastfeeding or the poor are not used to insult others. When such commonly used terms are rebranded as harmful something more than good manners is at issue. These are words through which a people understands birth, bodies, family life, community and their inter-personal relationships. Through the use of this vernacular a shared understanding of the conduct of everyday life is created. Once these words are condemned as unacceptable than the prevailing system of meaning becomes undermined. Those who insist on using the language that was transmitted to them by their family and community stand condemned for their crime against the new culture.

The term linguistic cleansing captures the current trend towards the policing of language. The brutal and violent dynamic driving linguistic cleansing was alluded to by David Barnhizer in the following terms:

    In the same way that a specific ethnic identity group seeks to “cleanse” a territory of other identity groups in what has come to be known as “ethnic cleansing” there are rapidly evolving language control strategies being implemented by aggressive special interests that are fairly described as “linguistic cleansing”. The aim of “linguistic cleansing” is to gain power over others’ speech and re-engineer culture into a form desired by the identity group implementing the strategy. This extends to the desire to eradicate traditional modes of expression that are claimed to “insult”, offend, emotionally harm or demean.(my emp) The real aim is to shape thought and consciousness by controlling the use of language and acquiring power through control of discourse.

Barnhizer’s argument that ‘the real aim’ of linguistic policing is ‘to shape thought and consciousness by controlling the use of language and acquiring power through control of discourse’ highlights its insidious and culturally damaging consequence. Humans do not merely use language the words they use defines who they are.

For many decades advocates of linguistic policing have argued that the target of their concern are words that intend to offend, to harm and to demean. However, in reality the words chosen for cleansing are often ones that have been used since time immemorial and were not designed to offend or to cause harm. People using the word female have no derogatory intent it is those possessing a censorious agenda who take it upon themselves to cast this word in a negative light.

Update, 17 November: Welcome, Instapundit readers! Have a look around at some of my other posts you may find of interest. I send out a daily summary of posts here through my Substack – https://substack.com/@nicholasrusson that you can subscribe to if you’d like to be informed of new posts in the future.

November 14, 2026

The Stellantis Brampton plant became an unforced political error for Carney

Filed under: Business, Cancon, Government, Media, Politics — Tags: , , , , , — Nicholas @ 04:00

The Stellantis (formerly Chrysler) auto manufacturing plant in Brampton, Ontario has been idle for a few years. Brokering a deal to sell the plant to Roshel, who manufacture armoured vehicles for domestic and foreign militaries, would seem to be a no-brainer for the federal government: renewed economic activity in Brampton, up-and-coming Canadian manufacturer expands production, and Stellantis gets rid of a facility they no longer need. Wins all around. What could possibly go wrong?

I heard someone say on CBC on Thursday that Stellantis is the weakest of the auto companies. That’s been true for decades. Previously known in North America as Chrysler, the company has had bailout after bailout.

Stellantis has been in the news of late for its decision to sell its Brampton auto assembly plant to defence firm Roshel.

The Brampton plant was announced as a project of American Motors Corporation in 1984 and opened in 1986. Despite the name, American Motors Corporation was controlled by Renault in France, and the company was having trouble.

In 1987, American Motors Corporation was purchased by Chrysler.

As much as I have loved many Chrysler products over the years, from my first car, a 1984 Dodge Omni, to a Chrysler LeBaron my grandparents gave me, to a great Caravan that carted around my kids, Chrysler, and American Motors before it, were always the sick car companies on the block.

I give you this background to explain that this plant has long been on the brink.

For the past several years, I’ve had politicians and auto executives push back on that idea, but I’ve known people who have been working in that plant on and off — far too often off — since the 1990s.

Could the Carney government have done something to try to save this plant?

Sure, they absolutely could have, but Carney doesn’t want to. He wants to call what Stellantis is doing a betrayal. He wants to pick a proxy fight with European-owned Stellantis by making it about Trump.

All that said, the surest way to bring this plant back would have been to try to strike a deal with the Americans. As I wrote in the Toronto Sun today, that was not in the cards for Mark Carney, who doesn’t want to score a deal if it will hurt him politically.

He chooses politics over economics time and again. Strange, considering he’s an economist and former central bank governor.

I was certain that the Brampton AMC plant had been there long before 1984, as I’d passed an AMC-branded factory many times when I lived in Mississauga before 1982, but it turns out that I was thinking of a different location, AMC’s Brampton Assembly plant.

On X, Martyupnorth comments on the situation:

Stellantis just sold the Brampton plant. After years of idling, after Ottawa threw hundreds of millions at them in 2022, after the production they promised got moved to Illinois the moment tariffs made Canada less competitive. It’s not like they didn’t try. They gave up.

This is what happens when you run a country on ideology instead of reality. High taxes, endless red tape, energy policy that makes everything more expensive, and then you act shocked when companies pack up and leave. Browbeating foreign investors, as this guest mentions, and threatening lawsuits after the fact doesn’t fix the underlying problem. It just tells the next company: don’t bother coming here.

Canada is not an attractive place to do business right now. The numbers keep proving it. The Trudeau-Singh Liberals (and now Carney) keep doubling down on the same approach that got us here … more subsidies, more threats, more speeches about “betrayal” … while the real message to investors is clear … “Stay away”.

Where’s Doug Ford in all this? Ontario put money on the table too. He can talk about protecting jobs all he wants, but the plant is gone. Reality doesn’t care about the press conference.

Ideology keeps losing. Reality always wins. The question is how much more of the auto sector, and how many more jobs, have to disappear before enough Canadians finally wake up to this?

My real fear is that Carney will execute the plan he had all along, and nationalize another industry. He’ll step in and buy the factory. That’s not a win, that’s an even bigger loss.

To the Liberals in Ottawa, appearances matter so much more than reality, and the idiocy around the plant sale demonstrates that again:

The Harry Potter books to Millenials are like Lord of the Rings to boomers

Filed under: Books, Britain, Media — Tags: , , , , , — Nicholas @ 03:00

On the social media site formerly known as Twitter, Devon Eriksen considers the relevance of J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter books to the Millennials:

After some recent trends, I finally decide to read the Harry Potter books.

And I came away with something I didn’t expect.

I came away with an understanding of what makes a generationally beloved classic.

It isn’t authorial skill. Rowling is certainly talented, but, at least at the time, she was also relatively unpolished, and the series has plenty of rough patches. Uneven pacing, awkward plots, exposition dumps, two-dimensional secondary characters. I could write quite a few lines about what might be fixed. And I probably will at some point.

But none of that matters.

Because a generationally beloved classic is almost never the best book of a generation. A generationally beloved classic is the book that most perfectly captures what that generation yearns for.

Hogwart’s School of Wizardry did that for millennials, just as the quest to destroy the One Ring did so for the boomers.

Boomers grew up hearing tales of recent history, and the heroism of previous generations, who got us through the great depression, and the great war. Their father, or grandfathers, or both, were heroes. But they were left growing up in the 1950s, a near-ideal time of growth, happiness, and prosperity.

Near-ideal isn’t ideal. Humans need goals. The boomers were left with no great struggles to fight, no great tasks to do, nothing that could make them feel like they measured up.

So they invented something. A new struggle. A moral struggle. They decided that, because the great depression, and the great war, had happened when the institutions of Western Civilization existed, therefore those institutions were responsible. That those institutions needed to be torn down, gutted, and rebuilt in the new Boomer Morality.

This was their great quest, what allowed them to imagine themselves heroes. As an added bonus, it allowed them to imagine that the men who fought WW2 were not. They were, after all, adherents of the old creed.

When the hippies took to the streets, chanting “fascist scum, your time has come”, they meant the very same people who had fought the Nazis.

Lord of the Rings dovetailed perfectly into this narrative. Its central struggle, its great quest, is not a martial struggle or a political struggle, but a moral struggle … the quest not to seize an object of power, but to destroy one.

Frodo was not some great warrior, or wise wizard. He was an innnocent, whose virtue was moral worth. The young, unaccomplished, and very small man had to resist the temptations of power, and to destroy it, because it was wicked.

Is it any wonder that the boomers decided to tear down and hollow out the institutions of society, rather than inherit and incrementally improve them?

Even to this day, any younger person who seeks power, wanting to improve the world, is subjected to any number of brain-dead aphorisms about Boromir and the Ring.

Never mind that Tolkien never intended any of this. Never mind that the Ring wasn’t a symbol of anything. It was a ring. It was evil not because it represented power … it was simply evil because it was made by evil for evil purposes, and possessed a malign will of its own.

LOTR, the way the boomers read it, fit perfectly into their worldview, and they imagine themselves perpetual revolutionaries, always fighting the evils of power, even now when they are 70 years old and own everything.

Which brings us to millennials. They grew up in the world that the gutting of Western institutions left us. They went to government schools run by characters straight out of a Franz Kafka novel, sent there by parents who inexplicably hated them from the time they were old enough to talk.

When they yearned, they didn’t yearn for a great moral struggle, or to tear anything down, or to be revolutionaries.

They yearned for a society that cared about them, for parents who loved them, for a civilization that saw them as the future, and invested in them accordingly.

They wanted to go to Hogwart’s. They wanted get a letter by owl, telling them that the reason they didn’t quite fit wasn’t because they were inadequate, but because they were special.

They wanted to be the special ones, the chosen ones, the boys and girls who lived. And that last sentence may sound a bit conceited … until you realized that when they wanted to be special, they wanted to be special in precisely the way that Harry Potter was special, the way that every child in a healthy family is naturally special … not because he is talented or great, but because his mother loved him.

This is what saved Harry Potter in the inciting incident of his young life. This is what millennials wanted for themselves. Not to be astronauts and war heroes and rock stars, but to fit into a place like Hogwarts. To be mentored by wise and caring elders like Dumbledore. To be part of a community. To have mothers who loved them.

To write a story like this isn’t necessarily to understand a generation, because it never seems to happen except by accident.

It is, rather, to help a generation understand itself.

That’s why fan fiction, with visions like this picture, matters. Not because it has so large a footprint as to change the world, perhaps, but because it represents the spirit of an age.

It tells us what people want. And if we look carefully, it tells us why.

November 13, 2026

Easy-mode discrediting anyone

Filed under: Media, Politics — Tags: , — Nicholas @ 06:00

At Astral Codex Ten, Scott Alexander provides a blueprint for discrediting anyone so you can avoid grappling with their actual arguments:

Here’s a fun argument you can use to discredit anyone at any time.

Start by calling them an arrogant fanatic with a totalizing ideology, someone who thinks they personally have solved all problems and can’t possibly learn from anyone who disagrees. If they have friends who agree with them, they’re a cult who collectively work to shelter themselves from any dissenting viewpoint.

Then your victim responds by presenting one hundred notarized affadavits describing times when they have engaged with their critics, spent years studying books by their critics to see what they could learn from them, and even changed their beliefs in response to criticism.

Then you spring the trap: “Ah, but you cherry-picked critics who operate within your worldview, a sort of loyal opposition. You continue to dismiss and exclude genuine critics who challenge your smug assumptions.”

This always works. If your victim protests that they do like and appreciate many critics with worldviews different to theirs, you object that no, those guys are also within the system. You meant a different guy, even further away from their own view. Oh, they read that one too? You meant an even more different guy. Eventually, no matter how cosmopolitan they are, you will reach someone they actually don’t respect — let’s say a Stalinist pedophile who believes the Papacy is a Jewish plot — and then you go ha! I told you that you rejected everyone outside your little bubble!

Everyone has people close to their ideology who they respect, and people far away from it who they don’t respect. Professionally, I work from a tradition of medicalized psychiatry influenced by figures like Kraepelin, Kline, and (sigh) Stahl. When I operate within that tradition — let’s say by prescribing escitalopram to a depressed patient — here are five circles of critics I might consider listening to:

  1. The Colleague: “Instead of prescribing escitalopram, you should prescribe bupropion, which studies show is equally efficacious with fewer side effects.”
  2. The Biopsychosocialist: “Instead of just using medication, you should treat depression with a balanced regimen of biopsychosocial interventions, including improved diet, better sleep schedule, and helping the patient overcome obstacles in their life.”
  3. The Freudian: “Have you even considered that the patient might be repressing his latent desire to kill his father and marry his mother? Maybe you should analyze him weekly for ten years.”
  4. The Zealot: “Mental illness is caused by separation from Christ/Mohammed/Buddha/Confucius. Your patient should seek forgiveness and let God/Allah/enlightenment/filial piety into their heart/soul/chakras/family.”
  5. The Scientologist: “Psychiatrists are hostile aliens from the planet Farsec. Mental illnesses are caused by body thetans under the influence of the evil overlord Xenu, which can only be removed through dianetics classes, especially the expensive ones.”

In practice, I devote a lot of time and energy to the Colleague and the Biopsychosocialist’s criticisms, a small amount to the Freudian’s, and very little to the Zealot’s and Scientologist’s.

If you portrayed me as a blinkered fanatic who refused to consider other views, I might object by talking about all the time I spent engaging with my colleagues and the biopsychosocialists. Then you could say that those are just loyal opposition within my own modern-20th-century-medicalized-psychiatry paradigm, but, if I’m so broad-minded, why don’t I engage more with Freudians, zealots, and Scientologists? I can only answer that I think those people are wrong. Then you could say “See, Scott admits that he thinks that his own ideology is the sole source of truth and that outside critics have nothing useful to contribute”.

This is what Eric Raymond calls a Kafkatrap, where any denial is further evidence of guilt. The victim insists “I do so listen to criticism! See, I draw my boundary of who to listen to way out here“, and points to some place very far away from him. The attacker answers “See! Everyone inside that boundary is within your worldview by definition, so you’re admitting that you refuse to listen to criticism from outside your worldview!”

Raymond coined “kafkatrap” during the first round of Social Justice Wars, and this argument figured heavily there. You’re in medicine? You read dozens of books by highly-educated critics of medicine all across the political spectrum? Ah, but have you engaged with this anthroplogist who says medicine is fundamentally racist because surgeons don’t start every operation with a land acknowledgment? Oh, you don’t take her seriously? Seems like you’re one of those insular elitists who think true outsiders, especially black outsiders, have nothing to contribute. If you get my drift, mein Führer.

Books for boys

Filed under: Books, Health, Media, Politics — Tags: , , , , — Nicholas @ 03:00

A few days ago, I posted a meme on social media from Hopalong Ginsberg which I thought was a useful encapsulation of a long-standing problem in the publishing world — that publishers have been consciously neglecting the male reader, especially the young male reader, in favour of the female audience — and the often noted lack of interest among male students for reading assignments in school. I commented “It’s amazing to consider the power (mostly female) school teachers have to utterly destroy young males’ interest in reading anything“:

On X, MeWe, and Gab, it got a few likes and that was it. On Substack Notes, however, it got a lot of attention and commentary (mostly positive) and a few who took it as a personal attack or proof that there’s no anti-male bias in publishing today. It’s always eye-opening when audiences can get radically different interpretations from the same source.

All that said, here’s something vittorio posted to X which I think is also relevant:

this is also why boys are reading so much less now that children’s publishing has become female dominated

men write archetypes. women write about themselves.

men write about heroes, villains, gods, monsters, extraordinary characters who embody something greater than themselves, heroes that boys can admire and aspire to become

women write characters who look like them, think like them, have their problems and insecurities, characters they can identify with and project themselves onto

men use writing as a vehicle for self-transcendence while women use it as a vehicle for self-recognition

it’s the difference between wanting to become Batman and wanting Batman to become you

it’s then obvious why boys craving the hero’s journey would rather retreat into video games than read yet another piece of autobiographical, gossip-filled, moralizing turboslop

if you want boys to start reading again you need to let men write again

November 12, 2026

The US Post Office resumes an old, old role – surveillance of dissidents

It’s nice when a long-standing institution goes back to one of its earliest roles … in theory. In practice, there should be a lot of questions about why the US Post Office took up responsibility for detecting and observing online dissidents:

We know that mission creep is a thing, but is it entirely necessary for every federal agency to try to reimagine itself as Big Brother?

OK, silly question. Of course, it’s not necessary for the Post Office — that’s the agency under scrutiny this time — to engage in mass surveillance. It just seems to be an activity in which all government bureaucracies inevitably engage. That’s the most logical explanation for why the U.S. Postal Service decided that it should monitor the internet for information about political demonstrations.

The Mailman as Political Cop

“The law enforcement arm of the U.S. Postal Service has been quietly running a program that tracks and collects Americans’ social media posts, including those about planned protests”, Jana Winter first reported in 2021 for Yahoo! News.

“Analysts with the United States Postal Inspection Service (USPIS) Internet Covert Operations Program (iCOP) monitored significant activity regarding planned protests occurring internationally and domestically on March 20, 2021”, according to a March 2021 bulletin from the iCOP that was included in the article. “Locations and times have been identified for these protests, which are being distributed online across multiple social media platforms, to include right-wing leaning Parler and Telegram accounts.”

Among the organizations alarmed by the disclosure was the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), which filed suit to learn more about the surveillance program. “After years of delays and technical failures that led the agency to lose access to a trove of emails discussing the program,” wrote EFF Deputy Legal Director Aaron Mackey, the organization was finally able to extract some key documents about iCOP from the postal cops this month. Others were apparently destroyed.

“The disclosures include a series of bulletins created from iCOP, which show that the postal service used the program in 2020 and 2021 to monitor and circulate information about a wide range of planned protests” from “across the political spectrum,” Mackey added. “They included a planned ‘Million MAGA March‘, a gun rights advocacy event and counter-protest in Virginia, a nationwide Save the Post Office Saturday protest, and planned protests in front of then-Postmaster General Louis DeJoy’s home in Washington, D.C.”

Reports revealed that postal investigators ran keyword searches on social media posts and created “anonymous, untraceable email and social media accounts”, the better to monitor Americans’ conversations. They applied Clearview AI facial recognition software to photos scraped from online platforms for comparison to a database of billions of images.

How do you say “useful idiots” en français?

Filed under: China, France, History, Media, Politics, Quotations — Tags: , , , , , — Nicholas @ 03:00

On X, Handre reminds us that we didn’t run out of useful idiots after the original batch of the 1930s faded … there were still plenty of them in 1968:

In 1968, teenage Red Guards were beating their professors to death with clubs in Beijing courtyards.

Meanwhile, Jean-Paul Sartre sat in Paris calling Mao’s Cultural Revolution a model of revolutionary democracy. The most celebrated intellectual in France looked at a country burning its own libraries and saw liberation. He sold the Maoist newspaper La Cause du Peuple on French street corners himself, holding it aloft like a sacrament.

Between 1966 and 1976, the Cultural Revolution killed between 500,000 and two million people. Schools shut down across the entire country. Students dragged teachers onto stages, hung placards around their necks, forced them to kneel on broken glass, then murdered them. The historian Bian Zhongyun, vice-principal of a girls’ school in Beijing, died on August 5, 1966, beaten by her own students with nail-studded clubs.

Sartre swooned at this, calling it the people governing themselves. Why did a man this intelligent get it this wrong? Sartre believed knowledge served power, that truth was whatever the revolution required, that the individual existed to be dissolved into the collective will.

So when Mao abolished the distinction between teacher and student, between expert and mob, Sartre cheered. He had spent decades arguing that bourgeois reason was a class weapon. Here was a regime taking him at his word and clubbing the reasoners to death. This is what economic illiteracy gets you.

Mises had already explained the calculation problem in 1920. Hayek explained dispersed knowledge in 1945. Sartre had access to both and chose the dunce cap of the collective instead, then handed out its propaganda on the Rue de Rennes.

He died in 1980, mourned by 50,000 followers, never having retracted a word about Mao. The professors of Beijing got no such funeral, only a philosopher in Paris explaining that their murder was freedom.

Update, 13 November: Welcome, Instapundit readers! Have a look around at some of my other posts you may find of interest. I send out a daily summary of posts here through my Substack – https://substack.com/@nicholasrusson that you can subscribe to if you’d like to be informed of new posts in the future.

QotD: Citizen Kane

Filed under: History, Media, Quotations, USA — Tags: , , , — Nicholas @ 01:00

Citizen Kane is barely even blah … until you realize that it was shot in 1941, and start comparing it to everything else shot in 1941. Citizen Kane looks like a Current Year piece, and that’s why it was so revolutionary — everything else in 1941 looks like they just pointed a camera at a Broadway stage and left it running. Pretty much every movie “trope” — the whole visual “language” of modern cinema (I believe the term d’art is topos) — was created by Citizen Kane. When it comes to modern moviemaking, nobody makes “an Orson Welles” movie anymore, because they’re ALL Orson Welles movies; after Citizen Kane, that’s just how movies are done.

Severian, “Period Piece”, Founding Questions, 2026-08-04.

November 10, 2026

“I felt like Howard Carter entering Tutankhamun’s tomb and waving a torch at the walls of hieroglyphics”

Filed under: Britain, Media, Technology — Tags: , , , , , , — Nicholas @ 05:00

Have you noticed that the widespread availability of emojis/emoticons/electroheiroglyphics has particularly influenced how younger folks communicate? Joanna Gray has, and has her concerns about the whole thing:

One of the markers future historians will use when describing the New Dark Ages will be the collapse in the use of the alphabet in favour of “Yookay Hieroglyphics”. A demoralising development has emerged: a whole new form of pictographic language whereby children and young adults engage in hours-long online conversations with each other without the need for any letters, texts or words. Such conversations largely occur on gaming platforms, Snapchat and WhatsApp, and mark a classic regressive step in civilisational decline.

Like the medieval laity who relied on church wall paintings and stained glass to learn stories, a growing proportion of our current population is now using only pictographic communication. This time, there is no divine knowledge behind the imagery – just inane slop. I shall try to use words to describe this new pictographic language that groups of teenagers I work with have shared with me. When first shown, I felt like Howard Carter entering Tutankhamun’s tomb and waving a torch at the walls of hieroglyphics in wonderment. Yookay Hieroglyphics are read vertically from top to bottom. If drawn on Snapchat, they often instantly disappear on reading or after 31 days, making linguistic analysis particularly fraught.

A useful starting point when attempting to read Yookay Hieroglyphics is to think of the wonderfully coloured whizzy strip of cherries, bananas, apples, horseshoes, numbers, etc. on a slot machine. Reams and reams of such images are being sent from one person to another within microseconds. It often begins with one pictographic innovator (teenager) photographing their face and sending their image; their friend replies with their face; what then follows is a rapid exchange of images from one to another, creating a roll of vertically read hieroglyphics: distorted face, laughing emoji, pic of pet, pet pic distorted, laughing face, feeling sick emoji, question mark, toilet gif, sick emoji, prayer emoji, pic of dragon, happy face, pic of person smiling, distorted pic, AI-ed moving image of that pic, cat video, pic of nails, nail art inspo, gif witch nails, cross face, face with witch filter on, lol emoji, pic of face with wizard filter, pic of wizard distorted, instantly made sticker of that image, lol emoji, red laser coming out of wizard eyes filter, OMG emoji … and on and on and on and on and on.

Because I am not of the emerging linguist tribe, I will be unable to fully convey the nuances and depth of the meaning in this sample conversation – indeed a paper has concluded that emoji-based language is more layered in adolescents than in adults.

Older Posts »

Powered by WordPress