It’s true that slavery caused the Civil War, if you use “slavery” as a synecdoche for two incompatible worldviews — the New England Mind vs the Mind of the Master Class. You can also argue that because of this, slavery was the proximate cause of the Civil War. However, if you try to make it into more than that — the final cause, the one and only cause — then you go badly off track, because slavery was a sideshow to a lot of things going on in Antebellum America.
There were lots of regional and even philosophical factions within the Democratic Party: “Hard shell” and “soft shell” Democrats, which had something to do with currency reform IIRC; “hunker” and “barn burner” Democrats (something about the territories, again IIRC), and so on. The best contemporary analogue I can think of — and it’s very rough, please keep that in mind — is the way “support for Israel” crept into all factions of the Republican Party. Most Republican voters don’t really care about Israel. The ones who do, care intensely, but even they don’t make “support for Israel” their number one concern when evaluating candidates. If you were a Republican candidate in any sane time — for purposes of argument, let’s say “before 2015” — you couldn’t come right out and say “Sorry, guys, you’re on your own” re: Israel, but you didn’t have to do much more than that.
But sometimes the stars align in such a way where it matters a lot. After 9/11, for example. Had W. not been in Israel’s pocket before that, he would’ve jumped in with both feet, out of what he saw as domestic political necessity. In the 1840s, you could be a Democrat voter and not really care one way or the other about slavery. Even after the Mexican War you could still ignore it, though it was getting much tougher. If you wanted to run for office as a Democrat you had to make a few vague gestures about respecting the Peculiar Institution, but you didn’t have to do any more than that if you were a “hard shell” etc.
But events moved in such a way that slavery became the overriding issue. By 1860, moderate Democrats were forced to make a very unpalatable choice: Give in to the pro-slavery lunatics, or turn the country over to a Republican fanatic who’s determined to drive us off a cliff. Even then they tried to split the difference — half the party voted for Douglas over Breckinridge — but that was the choice, and they made it.
The rough analogy — and again, it’s very rough — is 2016, where you could vote for a TV pitchman who promised to turn his foreign policy (such as it was) over to Tel Aviv, or you could vote for the drunk Dragon Lady who was promising to nuke Moscow when she wasn’t having seizures in parking lots.
That’s prewar. Postwar, and you have the massive problem of Reconstruction. There have been entire libraries written on this, of course, but the one that doesn’t get hardly any attention (because professional historians are all moron Marxists) is simple geography. At peak, the Union Army had just over a million men in the field. That’s a lot, but it’s a drop in the bucket compared to what you’d need to hold down the entire South militarily. I doubt a million-man army full of all the latest satellites and drones and neural net AI and all the other neato torpedo gizmos could do it. The American South is just stupid huge.
Given that, of necessity they acknowledged all those old distinctions between the various Democratic Party factions. Yeah, ok, you went along with the lunatics, but same deal with the all the (((morons))) at places like Z Man’s — you know Orange Man is Israel’s very best bestie in all the world, but you voted for him anyway, because Her Nibs was worse. In a situation where you have to have experienced people to run Reconstruction, that’s the best you’re going to do. You have to have them onside. If you outlawed the Democratic Party, lots of those guys would no doubt switch sides — the opportunists and grifters and carpetbaggers ye have with you always — but a lot more of them would have been permanently alienated.
Again, if it helps, and bearing in mind for the final time that this is a very rough analogy, imagine what would happen if the Brandon Regime passed a law forcing all the (((morons))) to wear yarmulkes, because in voting for Trump they proved themselves to be undying friends of Israel.
Severian, “Mailbag Part I”, Founding Questions, 2022-08-26.
November 18, 2026
QotD: Slavery, the Democratic Party, and the US Civil War
No Comments »
No comments yet.
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL



