It’s probably safe to say that Christie Blatchford isn’t a fan of Julian Fantino, the Conservative candidate in the Vaughan by-election:
Now when Gary McHale, then of Richmond Hill, first poked his nose into the occupation that was going on in the town of Caledonia south of Hamilton, and began in late December, 2006, organizing rallies for those who objected to the way the Ontario government and the OPP were handling the occupation, Mr. Fantino had just taken over as the OPP boss.
He immediately demonized Mr. McHale, not a Caledonia resident, as “an outsider” with “an agenda.”
In a flood of internal e-mails to the officers who worked for him (these later were made public as a result of Mr. McHale’s various disclosure requests in court) and in his public statements, the then-commissioner went to remarkable lengths to characterize Mr. McHale and his supporters, to borrow from one of the e-mails Mr. Fantino sent, as “interlopers who put their own personal agendas” ahead of the purportedly grand peace efforts at the negotiating table.
It was an astonishing use of the resources of the state against a private citizen who had done nothing but exercise the very freedoms guaranteed by the Charter.
Of course, what made Fantino such a “great cop” is exactly why the Conservatives want him on their team:
But the point is, for a man hailed as the Conservatives’ hot new law-and-order fellow, there are some real questions about his credentials, at least as they showed themselves in Caledonia where the rule of law was shattered, and a rather terrifying indication of his willingness to turn the full beam of his attention and power upon individuals whose only sin is to disagree with him.
In this regard, I’m afraid, Mr. Fantino seems a sadly good fit for a party whose approach to law-and-order strikes me increasingly as cartoonish.
It must be pointed out, however, that the Liberals also tried to recruit Fantino to run for them. That reflects just as badly on Michael Ignatieff’s party as it does on Stephen Harper’s party.
If he is elected by the voters of Vaughan, he’s rumoured to be a shoo-in for a cabinet position. That says it all for the federal Conservatives.
I wonder if anyone has done some ATIP on the Liberals who actually ran the show, vice putting all the blame on the head of the OPP. I don’t know what is true, but if the politicians in charge order you not to do anything, then you either follow orders or you don’t.
Just like the fake outrage storm over misreported stories from PEI about Geurgis and Wafergate, the media sees what it wants to see sometimes without digging. That is what bloggers should do, dig for the truth. Don’t take the media at its word, ever.
Comment by Dwayne — November 29, 2010 @ 12:07
I’m part-way through reading Blatchford’s book on the Caledonia affair, and so far it looks like the province was trying to pass the buck to the federal government. The provincial Liberal government must take at least some of the blame, as their overriding concern was to keep Caledonia from becoming as public as the standoff in Ipperwash had done. When in opposition, the Liberals had used the Ipperwash confrontation to attack the Conservatives. They were afraid that the same weapon would be used against them.
Comment by Nicholas — November 29, 2010 @ 12:51
That’s what I am thinking with an ATIP request. It would be hard to hide such orders from the politicos if the ATIP went to the OPP. I can’t imagine the embarrassment that the professional police must feel hearing about their neglect of duty. If the political masters told them to stand down and not cause trouble, to ensure that the native “protesters” were not bothered from the outside, it would be communicated somewhere. Or perhaps they were told that no matter what they did in the way of arrests, the Crown would no pursue the charges. I can’t say for certain, but there must be more to the story than what we have seen.
Comment by Dwayne — November 29, 2010 @ 23:47