{"id":62987,"date":"2023-10-04T01:00:20","date_gmt":"2023-10-04T05:00:20","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/quotulatiousness.ca\/blog\/?p=62987"},"modified":"2024-08-19T12:05:05","modified_gmt":"2024-08-19T16:05:05","slug":"qotd-the-witchburning-and-the-mandate-of-heaven","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/quotulatiousness.ca\/blog\/2023\/10\/04\/qotd-the-witchburning-and-the-mandate-of-heaven\/","title":{"rendered":"QotD: The Witchburning and the “Mandate of Heaven”"},"content":{"rendered":"

\"\"<\/a>Turning to more familiar Western examples, look at Germany, especially in contrast to England. Germany was on the forefront of every big social and economic change in the late Middle Ages, but you couldn’t blame their rulers for not handling it, because they didn’t have any. The minor princely states, the Electors of the Holy Roman Emperor, the Emperor himself, the Hanseatic League<\/a>, and what have you \u2014 what could any of them do in the face of plagues and economic dislocations and terminal papal corruption and the massive intellectual upheaval of the printing press, even if their authority extended more than a few miles in any given direction, which it didn’t?<\/p>\n

So they burned witches. The “European Witch Craze” of the 15th century has been a feminist bugbear for a long time, and one must naturally assume that pretty much all modern scholarship on it is uber-politicized hooey1<\/sup>, but it’s clear that there really were a lot of witch burnings in Germany in the 1400s. All that free-floating anxiety has to land somewhere<\/em>, and since it’s pointless to blame the Margrave \u2014 he of the one decrepit castle and three square miles of territory \u2014 “witches” are a prime target. See also “the Period of the Wars of Religion” \u2014 is it any surprise that the most famous witchcraft stuff came from Germany just before the Reformation<\/a>, or France in the depths of the religious wars<\/a>, or England<\/a> around the Civil War?<\/p>\n

Clearly something is wrong with the universe \u2013 the Mandate of Heaven<\/a> has been lost, not by any individual ruler necessarily, but by society. “Purity spirals” are also characteristic of these periods, and they quickly spiral out of control \u2014 see e.g. the Anabaptist Commune<\/a> at Munster, or of course the Puritans.<\/p>\n

Speaking of, the most famous-to-Americans example is the Salem Trials, and here we see all the trends converge. Not that the Puritans of Plymouth Bay would be so hubristic as to claim the Mantle of Heaven for themselves \u2014 Puritans were nothing if not ostentatiously self-effacing \u2014 but claim it they did, in deed if not in word, since Plymouth Bay was the closest thing one will ever get to a theocracy this side of Calvin’s Geneva (they burned their “witches”, too<\/a>). And they just as clearly lost the Mandate \u2014 economic dislocations, a devastating Indian war<\/a> brought about largely by their own hubristic incompetence, even a plague.<\/p>\n

The aftermath of all this is fascinating. COVID, of course, is our new witch panic, and feel free to prognosticate on our current situation based on the life of Cotton Mather. The colony’s hottest young intellectual superstar in 1693, he went all-in on “spectral evidence”<\/a> and the like, and by 1700 he was a joke<\/a> on both sides of the Atlantic. So, too, with “critical race theory” and all the rest. There’s a racial awakening happening, kameraden, no doubt about that, but it has nothing to do with the eggheads’ fantasies. Those are just witch panics, and while witch panics are devastating to those caught in them, the wheel always turns sooner than later …<\/p>\n

Severian, “Witch Trial Syndrome”, Rotten Chestnuts<\/em>, 2021-01-27.<\/p>\n

\n